Tuesday Telugu: Bhale Bhale Magadivoy, Nani Does Ghajini

That isn’t really a fair title, it isn’t exactly Ghajini.  It is a lot more than that, taking all of the “serious” versions of memory disorder films and making them into a joke.

Nani is so great.  He is so willing to make a fool of himself, and he does it so well!  There is no hesitation, no effort to make himself into a “hero” for the audience, he just wants to entertain and serve the plot.  And at the same time, he does the work of a real “hero” in a film, easily carries the whole thing on his shoulders, pulls us into the plot and makes it work for us.

He is also very very good at picking films.  At least from the little I have seen.  Everything I have seen him in, Eega to Ninnu Kori, works very well for his particular talents. Too well sometimes, Ninnu Kori ended up being a bit of a sad ending for me just because he was so clearly more interesting than the other hero.  So watching a Nani movie means you will get a great performance, you will get a good script, and you will get an actor who is able to show both of those in the best possible light.

In particular with this movie and Krishna Gaadi Veera Prema Gaadha , Nani is poking good-natured fun at the kind of hero and kind of movie that other actors specialize in.  The noble saintly hero, the evil rival, the authoritarian father, and so on and so on.  Only it is all slightly slanted, a bit kooky, just enough to reveal the insanity behind even the “normal” version of these stories.  What hero is that perfect?  What father that firm, what rival that evil?  No, makes much more sense when it is consciously crazy, when it is saying “this world is false and so are these people and aren’t we silly for believing in them”?

What makes it really fun is that the same actors playing the spoofy version are the ones who play the “serious” version in other films!  If you wanted to see Ajay in a slightly larger role and a slightly lighter role than he usually gets, this is the film for you!  Same with Murli Sharma.  Oh, and then there’s our heroine.  She’s fine, didn’t really jump out at me, Lavanya Tripathi.  Of course, she also has to struggle a bit because she is the one being fooled, not the one doing the fooling, which makes her role a lot less interesting.

Everything else is the same “normal” but bigger sort of thing.  The songs are the same love songs we would always get, but put in this odd world.  The love story is the same, the general outline and complications and so on.  The first meeting is straight out of Ghajini, probably not a coincidence, and I am sure there are other references I missed to other films.

 

But mostly what makes it soar is the plot, the incredibly simple set-up and the many many complications that layer on top of it.  A less ambitious film would have been happy with just one of these ideas, but this film was shooting for the stars, idea after idea gets stacked on top of each other, and Nani neatly juggles them all.

SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS

 

 

 

 

We open with a classic opening.  A dying old man, who wants to make peace with his son before he goes.  A young grandson who ties together the two older generations.  Or, does he?  No, he doesn’t.  Young Nani gets distracted and forgets to deliver the message, making the grandfather unable to clear his conscience.  Only the whole thing is filmed in bright colors with quick editing and slightly over the top acting.  It is all a joke, all of life and tragedy and everything is a grand joke.  People can be distracted by a shiny object from the most important thing in the world.

That’s what the whole film is about.  Our hero is a charming intelligent fellow, but he cannot keep his mind on one thing for more than 5 minutes, he is constantly distracted.  Not in a medically clear way, like in Ghajini with the complete erasure every few minutes, but just like humans are only more so.  You are on the way to an important appointment, and you run into a friend and start talking, and forget.  No huge tragedy or need for medical explanation, it’s just human nature but more so.

And our hero is a little too human to be a hero, but also more human in other ways.  That’s his introduction, Murli Sharma is looking at photos for his daughter and picks Nani out because he “looks like a hero”.  But then he tries to arrange a meeting and Nani is very unheroic.  That is, very unfocused.  A nice enough fellow, but if he runs into a friend on the way to meeting a potential father-in-law, he will sit and talk with him for 4 hours and completely forget the original purpose of the meeting.  Nani is handsome and charming and brave and all of these heroic things, but instead of using those skills to defeat evil and so on and so on, he is using them to hide his own weaknesses.

He has the perfect magical meeting with the heroine, just like in Ghajini, she is helping children cross the road while he is stuck in traffic.  And then he pursues her, completely forgetting that he is supposed to be on the way to donate blood to his sick boss.  And donates blood anyway, just because he follows her to the hospital, but accidentally donates it to the wrong patient.

Lavanya sees this as saintly, he donated to her young dance student, a total stranger, and didn’t even care enough to give his name.  She falls in love with his forgetfulness, in a way.  The way he does good things and then moves on without thinking any more of them.  Of course, she doesn’t realize that he doesn’t think any more about anything he does, he isn’t capable of it.

Throughout their romance, she keeps seeing the “hero” in him and he keeps playing that up.  Brings a fake little brother to take her dance classes, and when he is identified as a beggar, declares that he just wanted to help the beggar learn to dance.  Accidentally drops his keys in a beggar’s bowl, and accepts her interpretation that he gave his motorcycle to a beggar.  Forgets to wear shoes, and tells her that he gave them away to a poor old man.

 

It reaches the culmination in the sequence when he plans to go to her house on her birthday to declare his love, but instead ends up being there to see her sister-in-law in labor and rush her to the hospital.  With many accidental twists and turns as he gets lost, forgets where he is going, gets distracted by conversation, and so on and so on.  To Lavanya, this is an amazing heroic action.  To him, it is something he barely pulled off.  On the other hand, at least his intentions were good in this case.  He did want to get her to the hospital, want to help her.  And he managed to overcome all the obstacles, including those of his own mind, to make it happen.  He may not be quite the hero that Lavanya sees him as, but he also isn’t completely not a hero.

Ajay is the opposite.  He starts out appearing heroic, perfect, and so on and so on.  A hero cop, mature and competent and excellent marriage material.  We can see why Lavanya’s father Murli thinks he is a good prospect.  But that same night that Nani reveals once and for all that at heart he is good, Ajay reveals he is bad.  Lavanya is mistakenly arrested as a prostitute, and Ajay shows up to free her and declare that she is his “wife-to-be” and force an apology from the arresting officer.  It all appears very noble and wonderful.  Until Lavanya and her father leave, and Ajay pays off the arresting officer and casually declares that that should fix it, she will learn to appreciate him and agree to be married.  Ajay can do what he set out to do, has no human errors, but his intentions and what he sets out to do are bad.

Related image

(Ajay, you’ve seen him in stuff)

This would be enough plot for most movies.  Our forgetful hero playing tricks to hide his problem while romancing the heroine, that’s almost enough plot for 3 hours.  Add on a rival who is playing his own tricks, throw in a fight scene, and you could be done.  But no!  There’s more!  See, in order to avoid an engagement to Ajay, Lavanya declares she is in love and her father, being a reasonable man, goes off to meet the family of the man she loves.  Only, he hates Nani, because of the original failed engagement, so rather than reveal Nani as the potential groom, his family lies that he is just a relative and the real groom is his friend from work.  And so we have yet another plot!  Nani making it appear to Lavanya that he is the groom, while the rest of her family thinks it is the other man.  And trying to avoid and explain away suspicions when he and Lavanya are caught together.

All of this is delightful, but what makes the movie really worthwhile is the final twist.  Murli eventually figures out everything, breaks the engagement, and Lavanya ends up being kidnapped by Ajay.  At which point Murli calmly goes to Nani’s house and tells him he has known everything almost from the first.  He knew Nani was in love with Lavanya, and he knew Nani was struggling with his memory lapses.  He waited to see what would happen, and now this is the final test.  Can Nani manage to rescue Lavanya without getting distracted?  If so, it will prove that he is capable of being her husband and taking care of her.

This is so brilliant!  First, that Murli wasn’t the ridiculous blind and over-protective father, he was playing that role, in fact he was reasonable and understanding and wanted his daughter to marry the man she loved, so long as that man could take care of her.  And second, that he is a whole different kind of ridiculous, setting up a very filmi kind of challenge for our hero, can he rescue the heroine from kidnapping?  The challenge is ridiculous, and so is the expectation that Nani can carry it out.  The assumption is that his memory lapses are the only reason he couldn’t.  Otherwise, obviously, true love will win out and he will be able to beat up all kinds of people, find the hiding place, rescue her, and so on and so on.  It’s kind of a joke the characters are sharing with the audience, we are all part of this artificial world with strange standards, like the characters we fully believe that Nani can do all this because he is the hero after all, so long as he can overcome his other issues.

And he does it!  After a brief faint in the direction of failure when he seems to forget what he is doing, but in fact it was just to trick the henchmen.  After a whole movie of him playing the hero to hide his infirmity, now he is using his infirmity to hide his heroism.

That’s the point, the whole thing is just poses.  There is no “hero”, there is no “villain”, it is all in how it is presented, in what we see of it, in what we remember of it.  That’s what makes it so funny, this film, and all films once you stop to think about it.

(Also, the songs are hilarious.  The over the top saintly classical song for early in their love story, and he over the top fantasy sexy song for later)

Advertisements

21 thoughts on “Tuesday Telugu: Bhale Bhale Magadivoy, Nani Does Ghajini

  1. This is Nani’s biggest overseas hit. If I remembered correctly, it grossed more than a million dollars in US market. That has to be something, right? For a non-star non-action movie?
    My personal experience – I had so much fun watching this movie in the theatre. The Munnabhai spoof and the scene where the hero’s mother has to refer to her husband as a brother are particularly hilarious. On my second watch though, I thought this movie was a drag. The aforementioned two scenes were still funny. The rest of the movie got tiring very quickly. This is not one of those movies that is still funny once you know the jokes before hand.

    Like

    • Gentleman and Ninnu Kori also crossed the $1 Million mark but I think BBM is still Nani’s highest grosser.

      Actually I’ve seen BBM multiple times since I first saw it in the theater and I’ve always found it to be funny. Some thing like Ala Modalaindi, on the other hand, is something I don’t really find as funny anymore.

      Like

    • I forgot about the Munnabhai spoof! Another moment that makes you realize just how silly the original was by simply repeating it.

      On Tue, Oct 24, 2017 at 11:03 PM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:

      >

      Like

  2. Hey Margaret, it’s Lavanya not Navanya 🙂

    Like Spandana mentioned, I also had a ton of fun watching Bhale Bhale Magadivoy in the theater! I watched the movie with my best friend and we enjoyed the jokes and the songs a lot.

    If you want to see something of Nani’s that is totally out of his comfort zone, then you should check out Yevade Subramanyam. Vijay Devarakonda also plays an important supporting role in the movie. Here’s the trailer with subtitles:

    Another choice is Gentleman though it’s half-normal Nani movie and half-thriller. Here’s the trailer to that with subtitles:

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks! I’ll update the name. And I will continue to try to find Gentleman, hard to find with subtitles last time I looked. but that was before Hotstar came to America.

      On Wed, Oct 25, 2017 at 12:42 AM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:

      >

      Like

  3. Nani is the only telugu actor whose movie I’d pay to watch in a theater. He reminds me so much of SRK, not in the looks department obviously, but in that he started from being a nobody to being one of the most talented gifted actors in the Telugu Film Industry. Plus he adorable in the boy-next-door kind of way. He dances like a dream, and when he turns on the charm, there is no escape. He can single handedly carry a film on his shoulders. He can be intensely romantic (just like SRK), has dimples (just like SRK), and can act circles around his contemporaries. Ninnu Kori for example had three great performances, but for me, Nani’s role was the best of the three. Humour, Angst, Passion – he can depict all of that with just his eyes. The last scene of Ninnu Kori where he does his walk and covers his tears is my personal favourite. BBM is not my favorite movie of his. While the movie is funny in parts, I thought Ala Modalaindi was remarkable, and had fantastic performances from Nani and Nithya. Krishnagadi and Gentleman were both amazing. In Gentleman the pre-climax scene will give you chills. Nivetha and Nani are the SRK-Kajol of the TFI for me. They bring out the best in each other, and are just such a lovely pair.

    Like

    • Maybe I should just try to watching all the Nani/Nithya movies. Another way he is like Shahrukh, he works a lot! His filmography is a bit over-whelming when I try to figure out what I should watch next.

      On Wed, Oct 25, 2017 at 11:32 AM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:

      >

      Like

      • Yeah, you should try going through Nani’s filmography! He’s had 19 movies released so far and there aren’t any movies that are outright horrible. At least in the ones that I’ve seen so far.

        Like

  4. For sure watch Gentleman, and Yevade Subramanyam. Such different genres, he excels at both.
    In Tamil, he is outstanding in Veppam with Nithya Menon. It has got one of my favorite romantic songs picturized with Nani and Nithya:

    I can’t wait for his upcoming releases – Middle Class Abbayi, and Krisharjuna Yuddham (double-role). Hanu who directed Nani in KrishnaGadi has the most beautiful things to say about his acting. Hanu Raghavpudi is the Imtiaz Ali of romance in Telugu, for me. He has such an exceptional way of crafting romances. His heroines are strong willed and women of character, atleast in Andala Rakhshasi (Lavanya Tripathy), and KrishnaGadi(Mehreen). You are correct, he is a workaholic just like SRK, but I’m sure he will reach the top in no time if he keeps up giving hits. Seven consecutive hits for Nani with Ninnu Kori, which is a HUGE deal…

    Like

    • I can’t wait for Middle Class Abbayi and Krisharjuna Yuddham as well! Especially Middle Class Abbayi since it’s directed by Venu Sriram who made Oh My Friend which I really liked. Also since it’s co-starring Sai Pallavi! I’m also really excited for his movie with Nagarjuna which is to be directed by Sriram Additya.

      Have you seen Hanu Raghavapudi’s Lie? I didn’t like the part of the heroine at all in that movie. Plus she had a pretty small role.

      Like

      • No, I haven’t seen Lie yet. Nithin is not someone whose work I follow….Is it any good?
        Sai Pallavi and Nani combination will set the screens on fire for sure! Can’t wait. But something tells me her part in this one might be smaller than Fida. This looks to be a Nani show all the way…I’m not complaining by any means!
        Yes, heard about the Nagarjuna liason. It will begin sometime in March 2018, from what I’ve read. He’s really moving on up, and I can’t be happier. I’m also looking forward to his next collaboration with Hanu, in which he is said to be playing a military role. Hope it features Nivetha as well. So many exciting new projects. I’m thankful he does 3 movies a year. That too, all different scripts.

        Like

        • Lie was horrible. A movie that tries to be smart but it’s just a bunch of unnecessary twists.

          Oh yeah, I can’t wait to see Sai Pallavi and Nani together! I think her role will be smaller than the one in Fidaa but I have a feeling that her role will be pretty substantial. I’m just basing it off of the fact that Shruti Haasan had a prominent role in Oh My Friend.

          Along with the film with Nagarjuna, I’ve also read that Nani’s going to work with Kishore Tirumala (director of Nenu..Sailaja..) soon. That would also be a pretty interesting combination in my opinion.

          I love Nani being paired with Nivetha but I kind of want to see him work with Nithya again. Also Samantha since I loved them together in Yeto Velipoyindi Manasu.

          Like

          • I loved Yeto Vellipoyindi. His performance of “Priyatama…” was so beautiful, and I’m sure he totally improvised a lot of the moves. I don’t like Sam a whole lot, but she has her moments. But Yes, I would KILL to see him with Nithya again in a simple, no-holds-barred love story. I’m a sucker for the best friends falling in love genre. For Nani, I wonder if the day is 36 hours long! I sure hope he gets to work with Mani Ratnam, and Raja Mouli, and Trivikram. I get a little annoyed with these directors, as I feel they are always busy chasing the so-called “Superstars” like Mahesh Babu, or NTR.

            Like

          • Actually I’d read somewhere that Samantha turned down Nivetha’s part in Ninnu Kori, for which I’m actually thankful. Samantha I guess is the Deepika Padukone of the south, as all the biggies line up for her.

            Like

          • I feel like YVM is one of the most underrated movies. I loved both the performances and the songs in the movie.

            Nani and Nithya are so good together! I hope someone casts them together again.

            He was actually supposed to work with Mani Ratnam after he dubbed for the Telugu version of OK Kanmani. But those plans got dropped and Mani Ratnam ended up making Kaatru Veliyidai.

            I felt like Nani would have been really good in A..Aa.. instead of Nithin. But honestly, Trivikram is becoming too formulaic. A..Aa.. was such a dissapointment since it was like another version of Attarintiki Daaredi.

            One person I would love to see Nani work with is Sukumar. Nani’s not such a big star so Sukumar would have more freedom to experiment with it.

            Like

  5. Actually, Nani also does the stretched arms SRK pose in the song from BBM, where he first meets Lavanya. I remembered thinking at that time how similar to Shahrukh he is. His confidence on screen is extraordinary, and he holds you rapt in attention, sometimes hard to look at some other performance. Only notable leading lady exceptions being Nithya Menen, and Nivetha Thomas, who I feel match him performance-wise…

    Like

    • That’s part of what made the end of Ninnu Kori so depressing for me, Nivetha Thomas was this bright light onscreen, like Nani, and it felt wrong that the two most interesting people didn’t end up together.

      On Wed, Oct 25, 2017 at 12:06 PM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:

      >

      Like

      • As an afterthought, apart from exploring the “second chance” concept (I explained it clearly in Ninnu Kori thread), I guess the separation was deliberate. I say this because, Ninnu Kori had so much of K Balachander inspirations: Vizag backdrop, middle class lovers, girl’s family having a strong influence on her etc. But the biggest resemblance is that the girl didn’t want to avoid the marriage she never intended to enter, and did that for the benefit of her beloved. This is something Balachander did in the preclimax but it was the pre-interval here.

        Come second half, the resemblance turns strong. Nani getting slapped for losing control, a mistaken affair, private resolutions and finally the one who never belonged there leaves silently. Remember Rajinikanth dying before Kamal and Srividya in Apoorva Raagangal? Sure she was his wife, but he doesn’t belong there now. She and Kamal deserved to be together, and that Rajinikanth understood and left is purely Balachander’s auteur touch. Ninnu Kori too travels in the same direction, and things are bittersweet. Who knows, Nani might eventually find Nithya Menen as his mysterious facebook friend in the end, where he reveals their plan to meet! (Inspired from Kabhi Haan Kabhi Naa)

        Like

        • I would soooooo love that ending! thanks for that visual, and that too from a fav SRK film of mine. You are right, Nani’s character had shades of Sunil from KHKN. The mischief, the obsessiveness, the single-mindedness to the point of being selfish…

          Aaah K Balachander.! they don’t make directors like him anymore! or K Vishwanath for that matter. Gems!

          Like

  6. What I didn’t like about the movie was that Nani got a very bad deal out of the whole situation. I wish the story had a more interesting conflict other than Nivetha’s character giving Nani an impossible and (improbable) situation to deal with. The situation coul have been dealt with in far more interesting ways. The way it played out, any other ending other than Nani bowing out would have been fake. The film did have some memorable moments overall. In particular, the scene where he is drunk, and gets slapped by Nivetha’s character was so realistically done, and so unexpected. Nani was golden there. I don’t think any other actor would have been secure enough to allow equal screen time for the other leads, and share the spotlight, which Nani does (like SRK). In all his interviews, he has nothing but praise for his costars, and was so invested in the other leads parts as well. Truly a team player, and as he rightly remarks – Nothing or No one is bigger than Cinema.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s