2017 DCIB Hindi Film Awards Best Movie, Editor’s Choice: It’s a Sidharth Malhotra Comeback story!

Well, here is a shocker, after winning the worst actor award last year, Sidharth landed in the best Hindi movie (I think) of 2017.  Not that he has become a better actor, he is just way way better cast this year than last year.

If I am looking for a film which was exciting, different, and perfectly put together frame by frame, it’s Ittefaq.

Image result for ittefaq poster

There were a lot of good movies this year, as I mentioned in my “surprisingly good movie of the year” post.  But they were all small movies.  There was no great grand massive film (yes yes, besides Bahubali).  All the “big” films somehow failed.  Some of them simply by becoming “big”.  By adding on budget and expectations and everything else until the poor simple little plot was tottering under the weight of it all.  But among the “little” films, there were many gems. Small stories about small people and their small lives, beautifully presented.

It is the presentation that sets Ittefaq apart.  Good casting, sure.  Great script, absolutely.  Original idea, yes (I know, it’s a remake, but it’s an original way of attacking a remake).  And even an interesting sense of place, that place being the mixed complex interactions of the wealthy Bombayites, the NRIs staying in luxury hotels, and the locals cleaning up behind them.  But most of all, it is the brilliant camerawork, editing, and overall direction of it.  This is a very confident debut film.

The other interesting film that keeps coming up this year is Bareilly Ki Barfi.  Which was also produced by BR Chopra films, along with this one.  It’s an interesting combination, two very different films, both with a strong director’s hand guiding them, and a complicated original story that is hard to sell in one sentence.  Bareilly could have won my “best of”, if it had been a little wilder, a little stranger, a little more different.  Maybe Ashwiny’s next film will be that different kind of film.  Now that producers have slightly more faith in in her, they may take a bigger risk.

(This song, for instance, was all chopped up and moved back to the start of the film instead of after Ayushmann’s introduction.  Why?  Probably wouldn’t have happened if Ashwiny had total control top to bottom)

Abhay Chopra, he lucked out, he was born into people having faith in him.  His best friend Ranbir Kapoor, his cousin Aditya Chopra, they weren’t officially involved, but they certainly helped to arrange the meetings that got this film made, got Abhay in to present his story to Shahrukh, who agreed to produce, and Karan Johar, who co-produced and helped coordinate the publicity campaign.

Yes, he was lucky, it is a little unfair.  But the talent shown in this film, that’s more than just being “lucky”.  Heck, it’s more than just talent!  This is precision, perfection, hard work.  He had a great idea for a story, and then he worked and worked and worked, every shot at just the right slightly off-kilter angle, every scene lit in the perfectly disturbing manner, every line of dialogue written and delivered in just the right way.

Abhay was a little lucky in one other way, in getting Akshaye to be in his movie.  I already talked in yesterday’s post about how Akshaye was so good in this role, he almost won best character of 2017.  And he really does make the movie.  Without him, it would be unwatchable.

But then, the film was designed around his character being there, like that.  It was supposed to be Shahrukh originally, which tells me that Abhay always knew the detective was the most important piece.  That’s the key to these mystery stories, the most important key, knowing that the audience wants to know more about the victim, the murderer, and the suspects.  But they have to love the detective.  If it wasn’t Akshaye, it would have been someone else, Nawazuddin or Irrfan or any other not-quite-star who is still a brilliant actor, and a charming presence onscreen.  Heck, Anupam Kher could have played it!

Image result for ittefaq poster

(See how Akshay is the center of the poster?)

And once Akshaye was in place, the other pieces settled around him.  A young actress with a pretty face that could be modeled into an off-puttingly fake look.  A young actor who is perfectly handsome in a way that makes you want to trust him.  Fill in with a few more good character actors for the police officers and the other suspects.  And you have all the ingredients that could make a good film.

After that, it was just a matter of making the best film they could, without over doing it.  Putting in just enough, but not too much.  You know how when you start college and your teachers tell you that it is harder to write a short paper than a long one and you think “yeah right”.  And then you come to realize that they are absolutely right, it is much harder to leave things out than put things in?

That’s what this film is.  The paper that is just the right length, even though it would have been a lot easier to make it longer.  Abhay could have added more songs, costume changes, more scenes with Akshaye at home, maybe a subplot or too.  But he resisted.  It is an aggressively stripped down and simple film, with every small part of it perfectly done, no corners cut.

That’s why it is the my winner for the “best” film.  There were other movies that did other things better.  Tumhari Sulu has stronger relationships.  Bareilly Ki Barfi has a more complicated plot.  Raabta has a better love story.  A Gentleman is a lot funnier and has better songs.  Jab Harry Met Sejal has better acting.  But this is just a perfect little movie, start to finish.

15 thoughts on “2017 DCIB Hindi Film Awards Best Movie, Editor’s Choice: It’s a Sidharth Malhotra Comeback story!

    • All of the costume is brilliant, but his everyman but still distinctive look is really something special.

      On Mon, Jan 8, 2018 at 10:23 PM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:



  1. I watched the original this year in preparation for this one, but still have to wait a bit longer to see it. I think it’s out on DVD already, so shouldn’t be too long…maybe I’ll “find” it on the interwebs tonight:) Though it seems like a movie to see on a bigger screen than my laptop so I might wait. I’m getting a 25 DVD order from Induna today anyway…all I’ve already seen and that will keep me busy putting those away!

    Also, finally saw Shubh Mangal Saavdhan and Chef. SMS was as fun and great as expected (that Ayushmaan is really fast becoming a big favorite…he’s just so charming and deceptively sexy) and Chef was so boring but had a few small moments of sweetness. Saif isn’t sometimes the best actor when it comes to subtle facial expressions. I blame the botox.


    • While I was googling for this article, it popped up on youtube for me. Legally. It’s available for streaming rental now, if your TV is set up for that.

      So glad you saw SMS! It’s really a sweet story, in some ways I liked it even better than Bareilly Ki Barfi.

      On Tue, Jan 9, 2018 at 8:04 AM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:



      • Maybe I’ll do that…I’m subscribed to Amazon Prime (which now includes Heera movies, yay!), Netflix, and have trials of ErosNow and Hotstar that I will probably let lapse (just rejoined to see SMS and some others). So I really want to wait until they pop up on those!

        My only complaint on SMS was that the ending seemed a little rushed or something, but I did like the core love story better in SMS.


        • My understanding is that the Tamil original on which SMS is based (I think maybe even the same director?) was a little longer and more complicated, the friends had more to do in it and stuff. I bet it had a slightly different ending, because this ending felt like they didn’t know exactly how they wanted to resolve it, didn’t have all the pieces in place, and so they just did a big action scene with Jimmy Shergill. Although I really liked the ending-ending, that it wasn’t all fixed immediately, they just relaxed and let it take the time it took to be resolved.

          On Tue, Jan 9, 2018 at 8:18 AM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:



          • Yep the resolution of the problem was well done, but the Jimmy Shergill thing was weird (and I’m all for Jimmy Shergill things usually). Wonder if it’s worth watching the original…


          • I haven’t seen the original, so if you do watch it, report back!

            On Tue, Jan 9, 2018 at 10:29 AM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:



          • The Tamil original was directed by the same director. And yes, the friends did have a lot more part to play in making the guy understand that the focus was not meant to be only on him. Also, in the Tamil movie, the girl had to undergo the regressive ritual which finally makes her snap at him. And they elope before the actual wedding and have a really pretty dream like wedding near a beach. It wasn’t as dramatic as Shubh Mangal Saavdhan. Also, I loved the hero’s balancing act between his wife and fiance, which was missing in the Hindi version.


  2. “By adding on budget and expectations and everything else until the poor simple little plot was tottering under the weight of it all.” Expectations may have killed the Indian audience for JHMS and now I’m thinking it will ruin Zero with a year’s worth of publicity.

    Like the original Ittefaq, but thought Akshaye really made Ittefaq work; so intense. Bareilly Ki Barfi and Shubh Mangal Saavdhan were fun to watch but I really enjoyed Raabta, A Gentleman and JHMS better.


    • Have you voted yet? I would love to count your views in the official tally (you can ignore categories you aren’t sure about). I’m just nervous about forgetting comments put on other posts when I do my final count.

      I kind of want to do another article just looking at Raabta, A Gentleman, and JHMS. Movies with decent budgets and decent promotion campaigns that still somehow were strangely overlooked. And are overlooked even now, I’m not really seeing them mentioned in the end of year round up conversations, except for JHMS as part of a Shahrukh Khan conversation.

      On Tue, Jan 9, 2018 at 11:09 AM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:


      Liked by 1 person

      • I would love to see this post. I would also like to hear your readers articulate theIr thoughts on why they didn’t like these 3 films, so I can see what I’m missing, and to expand the way I look at films.
        Perhaps that post is where we could have that discussion.


        • Yeah, it’s an interesting thing to think about, Bareilly Ki Barfi and Running Shaadi and the others like that, we can see where they went wrong-ish. A lowkey promotional campaign, small release, never really had a chance. But what about the films that had a decent shot and somehow failed to hit? Chef would be another one.

          On Tue, Jan 9, 2018 at 5:48 PM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:



  3. Pingback: 2017 Hindi Film Awards, Editor’s Choice: Favorite Hindi Film of 2017, A Gentleman | dontcallitbollywood

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.