2017 Hindi Film Awards, Editor’s Choice: Favorite Hindi Film of 2017, A Gentleman

It’s a Sidharth blow out!!!!!!!!  Best film yesterday, and my favorite film today.  Not a coincidence exactly, less about Sidharth choosing good movies/good movies choosing him, and more about the level of star who is still allowed to experiment and risk failure.

A Gentleman is such a cool movie.  Because it knows it is a movie.  It knows it is ridiculous and over the top and fun.  It isn’t trying to impress anybody or be different from who it is.  It is that weird kid in class who laughs at their own jokes and wears funny bright colored clothes and eventually you realize they are having way more fun and are way more interesting than all the carefully “normal” looking kids.  And that’s the real “cool” kid, the kid who lives their life for themselves, not anyone else.

(See?  This is not a “cool” song.  This is an actually cool song)

I came close to choosing A Gentleman as the Best movie yesterday.  Because, like Ittefaq, it feels like it is exactly the movie they set out to make.  The best possible version of itself with nothing added or removed.  But I looked deep into my soul and eventually decide that, objectively speaking, Ittefaq is the better film.  A Gentleman gets a little laggy right at the end, before the final confrontation.  And there is no performance that quite reaches the peak that Akshaye got to in his role in Ittefaq.  And the camerawork and editing, while very very good (certainly better than 99% of the other stuff that came out of the Hindi industry last year), wasn’t at that level of absolute brilliance that Ittefaq reached.

But I still like it better than Ittefaq!  Or anything else that came out last year.  It’s fun and funny and just makes you smile to watch it.  Well, makes me smile.  I could watch it over and over again, and have, and I enjoy it just as much on each watch.

(I saw this trailer at least 6 times in theaters before other movies, and each time I didn’t just enjoy it, I did a little cheer for it)

Which brings me to Sidharth Malhotra.  The Big Name films, they are no longer made for re-watching, they are made for opening weekend.  Sometimes rewatching AND opening weekend, but if you have to pick one or the other, it will be opening weekend every time.  I’m not even talking about the Khans, I’m talking about Ajay, Akshay, even Varun and Ranveer and Ranbir.  If a producer or a director is hiring one of them, it is part of putting together a package that will sell tickets that very first Friday, sell a lot of tickets.

So, why do you hire Sidharth Malhotra?  Or Ayushman Khuranna or Rajkumar Rao or Sushant Singh Rajput?  It’s because you aren’t interested in that opening weekend package.  I mean, you wouldn’t turn down a bigger star if they offered, but opening weekend is not your goal or your focus.

(This is such a weird movie.  Because if you watch it, it is definitely not an “opening weekend” film, there are too many funky things that you can only appreciate on a rewatch, besides the lack of star cast.  But the promotional campaign packaged it as an “opening weekend” film, including throwing in some songs and “bigger” moments than the story really needed.  Very strange.)

At this point I am more interested in seeing a Sidharth Malhotra movie than a Salman Khan movie.  Not because Sidharth is a better actor than Shahrukh, or better at picking scripts, but because a Sidharth Malhotra movie is a lot more likely to take risks than a Shahrukh Khan movie.

Bringing it back to A Gentleman, this movie is definitely risky!  It’s a black comedy, a rare genre for Hindi film.  Not totally unheard of, but rare. What’s really risky is the content of the comedy.  Like all comedy, it is situational and specific.  But it is specific to the NRI experience.  Not the bleak and dramatic NRI experience, or the fantastical perfect NRI experience like films usually show.  But the sort of day to do tedium of it.  The crowd at my local movie theater LOVED this film.  Laughed so hard I couldn’t hear all the lines.  Practically applauded when it was over.  So that one particular audience would understand and love every bit of this film.  But that’s a super particular audience!  NRIs who are ready to laugh at themselves.  Essentially, this is the audience that would watch a stand-up special with Russell Peters, or a crossover comedy like The Guru.  Very hard to get that audience in to see a traditional (seemingly) Hindi film.

Judging by how crowded my theater was opening night, I am guessing the publicity campaign worked in alerting folks that something special was coming out.  At least, the folks who would be going to the all Indian theater, the ones who still have a toe in the traditional NRI community.  But I’m not terribly surprised that it failed in most other theaters.  I would have loved to see it get more of an off-beat crossover comedy kind of release, would have been perfect for the same crowd that loved Meet the Patels.  Or even something like My Big Fat Greek Wedding.

Image result for brown nation

(You realize Netflix now has 3 American desi comedy series running?  Maybe more if I am forgetting one.  Clearly, the audience is there for this kind of comedy, this film just didn’t reach them.  It’s on youtube now, maybe…..)

I’m not an NRI, but I felt strangely at home in that theater opening night.  Because I am that person who likes mainstream snarky American comedy, and also has a toe in traditional NRI culture.  I was able to appreciate the jokes as though they were written just for me, because they were written just for me.  It’s like Raj & D.K. sat down and said “Let’s be nice to Margaret, we will make something special just for her because we love her more than all the other people in the world.”  They did all this just for me, how could this film NOT be my favorite?

7 thoughts on “2017 Hindi Film Awards, Editor’s Choice: Favorite Hindi Film of 2017, A Gentleman

  1. I kept telling myself that I’d get around to this movie eventually, but this post has convinced me to watch it ASAP. I love Sid, but I wasn’t too into films in 2017, so it got pushed aside, but now I’m super pumped to watched this!


  2. I really liked this movie, and was surprised at some of the negative reviews it got. I think it’s cos like you said, it was very easy for the American-Indian population to connect with it. Some of the humor (like the one with Hussain Dalal’s Asian wife and family) were so funny but probably very easy to miss for a pure Indian audience. Also, too much action maybe? Some of it felt like it was added to extend the running time. And I also loved the last scene, Siddharth was perfect casting.


    • Yeah, that heist sequence at the end is what I was thinking of when I mentioned it feels “laggy”. Definitely seems like it should have gone from the hotel scene right to the final house shoot out, the heist was just there to mark time. Although it was also very well done, lots of clever bits and so on, just felt a little like we were waiting for the “real” plot to start up again.

      On Tue, Jan 9, 2018 at 5:48 PM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:



  3. I’m glad this movie won because this is one of the few Hindi movies I watched in 2017. I agree with you that 2nd half dragged a bit but the rest of the movie was so much fun!!


  4. Pingback: News Round-Up: SRK Gets an Award, Shraddha Gets a Movie, Salman Gets a Death Threat, Vidya Gets Indira | dontcallitbollywood

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.