Discussion Post: Are You Watching Soothing TV Mysteries Like Me? Let’s Recast Poirot and Murder She Wrote!

I’ve done this before, but I have a really good feeling this time! Everyone’s home, binging on Poirot and Hastings and Jessica Fletcher. Time to CAST this thing!

Jessica Fletcher! Retired high school English teacher, widow, small town lover. She writes a mystery novel that turns into a surprise best seller, and starts a second act of life traveling to writing conferences, or to visit old friends, all over the world. Also, coincidentally, solving murders everywhere she goes, and also back in her hometown. In her hometown, she is joined by the younger ex-city cop sheriff, and her beau, the local doctor and a widower.

Okay, Who Can Play Jessica Fletcher?

Dimple Kapadia

Dimple Kapadia - FC - Home | Facebook

Shabana Azmi

Shabana Azmi On Being Cast In Spielberg's Halo And Why She Likes ...


Rekha - IMDb

Jaya Bachchan

Jaya Bachchan - Wikipedia

Zeenat Aman

Zeenat Aman - Wikipedia


Next question! The BBC version of Poirot is similar but different from the books, and I want to recast the BBC version. Poirot, fussy gentleman of a certain age who loves his clothes and his furniture. Hastings, about 10 years younger than Poirot, a bit dim, loves his cars. They travel the world together, share a home and a life, Hastings makes Poirot smile with his little charming ditzy moments, Poirot makes Hastings smile with his fussiness and constant politeness. Who can play these charming gentlemen?


Anupam Kher

Anupam Kher - IMDb

Boman Irani

Boman Irani: I'd terrorise Rajkumar Hirani if I get no role in ...

Irrfan Khan

Angrezi Medium': 6 times Irrfan Khan proved that he is a hero in ...

Nawazuddin Siddiqui

Nawazuddin Siddiqui - Wikipedia



Sid M.

5 things about Bollywood actor Sidharth Malhotra – ex-boyfriend of ...

Harsh Kapoor

Harshvardhan Kapoor - IMDb

Arjun Rampal

Arjun Rampal - Wikipedia

Kunal Kapoor

Bullying is prevalent in society: Kunal Kapoor | Deccan Herald


I welcome other casting thoughts, who should play Jessica’s doctor beau, who should play Inspector Japp, and so on. But I think if we can just get Jessica, Poirot, and Hastings figured out, we will be well on our way.

19 thoughts on “Discussion Post: Are You Watching Soothing TV Mysteries Like Me? Let’s Recast Poirot and Murder She Wrote!

  1. Anupam Kher would make a good Poirot, with his egg shaped head 🙂
    Boman Irani would be a good Hastings. I don’t like the idea that Hastings is a much younger person than Poirot. I nominate Dimple Kapadia as Jessica. She will be perfect. Inspector Japp could be Vicky Kaushal


  2. I was writing a comment but it disapperaed in the middle 😦 Maybe it’s in spam.

    I was saying that for me Shabana Azmi as Mrs Fletcher. And as the doctor – Gajraj Gao.

    For Poirot, everybody except Anupam. Yes, he would be good in this role, but I can’t stand him as a person and don’t want him working.


    • It feels like it should be Neena Gupta if it is Gajraj Rao, but then I like Shabana so much, I will allow it.

      If not Anupam, what about Naseeruddin? Great as a person, and also as ana ctor.

      On Thu, Apr 9, 2020 at 9:36 AM dontcallitbollywood wrote:



  3. I don’t think Anupam is believable as that character. I don’t have faith in him projecting the right amount of haughtiness and the precision. I just watched him do a similar character in Hotel Mumbai, and while it worked, he has an undercurrent of emotionality and chaos. What we need is someone who can do a cold, withering stare. Nawazuddin Siddiqui has my vote, although Arjun R would have got it if he wasn’t physically the wrong type. I’d love to put forward Govinda, but loooooooooool. He could be Holmes because Holmes has a chaotic inner life, but Poirot does not.

    Hastings, Kunal absolutely.

    I won’t take anyone but Dimple for Jessica Fletcher. She has the warmth.

    I have a lot of Poirot feelings.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Wait, Nawazuddin Siddiqui and Kunal Kapoor? Aren’t the ages wrong? Also, are we supposed to believe that Nawazuddin can pull someone like Kunal?

      Also, for Poirot, can we make him Parsi instead of French? Fussy, wears the Parsi style clothes and food, has a funny name, people make assumptions about him, there is that frisson of tension in his relationship with Hastings because Hastings has a different background?

      Also, maybe Hastings is part of an old landed family in India? So keep the hunter hobbies and the blindness to anything outside of his class experience? While Poirot is Bombay born and bred.

      If Dimple is Jessica, Seth the doctor is Rishi? That seems to be the general vote, but you can go against it.

      On Thu, Apr 9, 2020 at 10:23 AM dontcallitbollywood wrote:



      • Kunal is slightly younger, I don’t think it’s a huge problem. I guess you could pick Harsh instead because he’s 1. stupid and 2. privileged which would work with the character.

        Excuse you, Poirot is Belgian. I don’t know what the Indian equivalent for Belgian is. Part of a deeply disputed over and easy to mistake for somewhere else part of the country but not Kashmir.

        No, I don’t like Rishi. I can’t think of anybody sweet enough.


        • Oh oh! What about Sri Lanka? So India isn’t directly involved but has a connection, Poirot can still be a refugee, and this means he is Tamilian which means we have a whole new wealth of potential actors. Maddy?


          • Sri Lanka is excellent, just enough racism to make it work.

            Tamil actors are hard, their image doesn’t really work very well for it. I guess Maddy is probably the best fit but idk, none of them seem haughty enough.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.