Yash Chopra is so good! Even in Aaina, one of his weaker films, his brilliance stood out. And then Darr was just fantastic. But I honestly think Lamhe might be his greatest triumph.
(if you like Sridevi movies, I also did a post on English/Vinglish and Chandni went up today)
Lamhe! This movie is so good, and so subtle, and brilliant, and no one appreciated it when it came out. It was also the first movie Aditya Chopra worked on. I’ve heard rumors that he may have had a large hand in directing it (just like those rumors that Yashji helped him with DDLJ). Adi was on vacation from college during filming and helped his Dad with everything. And then it came out and flopped, and it broke his heart.
Supposedly he watched it over and over again in the editing bay and finally decided that it would have worked if they cut the scenes with Sridevi as a little girl, because it slowed down the film and gave it the creepy incest vibe (since she was idealizing Anil since she was a little girl). He wanted his Dad to re-cut and re-release the film, but Yashji told him, basically, “that’s how it goes sometimes, no take-backs.” And then in years since, it has become a cult classic on TV and VHS and now DVD and bluray.
(Although, then we would have missed out on some luminous Waheeda Rahman time)
Even if Adi was strongly involved, it is still distinctively a Yash Chopra film in a whole bunch of ways. One of my favorite things about him is how strong his heroines are. He never gets credit for that, he’s not considered, like, big on “women’s issues”, but I think actresses get it, because there is always a huge rush when he is casting to be a “Yash Chopra heroine.” Like in this, both Sridevi’s were so strong and complex and clear on what they wanted. And Sridevi got to show her chops by playing such different roles. It’s really her movie. Just like Dil To Pagal Hai belongs to Madhuri and Karisma more than Shahrukh, and Jab Tak would belong to Kat and Anushka if Kat were a better actress. You don’t have to do a movie about spousal abuse or forced marriage or something to show strong women, just showing these woman could survive with or without a man and want to choose their own path in life, that’s something.
Speaking of Jab Tak, I feel like the two heroines and the two love stories in that are supposed to be saying the same thing Yashji had been saying over and over again in his entire career, that love has to be both passionate and reasoned. And some relationships will fail, while others succeed, depending on the people and the circumstances.
In his prime, Yashji would have had some growth and change built into the Kat-SRK relationship in Jab Tak. Something like, maybe she actually did marry someone else and was happy with him and became a mother, and then years later he died and she went back to her first love. That would have a kind of beauty to it. Or maybe she married someone else and managed to be happy with him, and years later SRK meets her again and resolves his feelings for her, and that lets him move on with Akira. Or even just more clearly showing that they were too immature and inexperienced to be married at the beginning of the film, but after ten years they had suffered and grown and could be together, kind of like Love Aaj Kal. It feels like he was trying to say something like that with the last scene, and with the Rishi/Neetu cameo, about how love has to wait for its time. Only I just didn’t get that from the way it was structured. And 20 years earlier, in his prime, that is the kind of story Yashji knocked out of the park!
Actually, he did do it back in the 70s with Kabhi Kabhi. Ridiculously awesome movie with a million love stories and chase scenes and explosions and stuff, but tucked into the heart of it is that a young couple was passionately in love in college, broke up when her parents arranged her marriage, and now 20 years later they come face to face. And the hero of it all ends up being her arranged husband who never knew any of this, and when he finds out, says basically “you know, I don’t care! Maybe you will always be her first love, but I’ve been married to her for 20 years, and raised a son with her, and that’s more important than any college love story.”
(Who’d have thought this marriage would work out?)
Lamhe came out about 10 years after Kabhi Kabhi and over 20 years before Jab Tak, and it may not have gotten the kind of audience appreciation it deserved when it was released, but I think it is possibly his best film. At least, one of his best. Up there with Silsila and Deewar (although Deewar is much more an Amitabh and Salim-Javed movie than a Yash Chopra movie). By the time he made Lamhe, Yashji was no longer worried about appealing to a broad audience, or exploring “big issues”, he just wanted to tell a story that interested in him in an interesting way.
Which brings me to SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS
Lamhe unfolds in such an interesting fashion. I don’t want to say their are twists, really, more just slight turns in the road, as characters go to places you don’t necessarily expect them to end up. Anyway, don’t read this if you haven’t watched the movie yet, because it is kind of fun to see how everything plays out! But, if you have seen it, or are one of those people (like myself) who enjoys knowing where something is going as they travel along, then here is a brief synopsis:
Anil Kapoor is a wealthy young orphan, raised in London by his devoted nanny. He travels back to the ancestral land in Rajastan as a teenager (just come of age, so either 18 or 21, but it feels more like 18). He meets the girl next door, from the only family of equal standing in the area, Sridevi. She is considerably older than him, perhaps 25 or even 30, and unmarried. She treats him kindly, her father approves of him, and Anil spends a lot of time with Sridevi, and falls in love with her. But, before he can speak his love, her father dies. Her evil relatives come in to take possession of her house, and Anil finally, truly, “comes of age” when he takes charge and arranges things and protects her, like a real lord of the manor and leader of the area. His nanny is proud of him.
But, he also finds out that Sridevi is in love with someone else. The whole time he thought she cared for him, she was just being nice to a lonely little boy. She is in love with an air force pilot, has been for years, and but her father objected. So she and her lover were just patiently waiting for the situation to change so they could be married. That sadness and sweetness Anil sensed in her was not love waiting to blossom, but love that had already blossomed and was now lying (laying?) fallow.
Anil decides to arrange her marriage, his final duty as the new head of the household and lord of the area, and then return to London and try to forget. Sridevi is ecstatically happy with her new husband, but keeps Anil in her thoughts, making sure to write him and stay in touch. And, because she stays close to Anil, and because her father is dead and her evil relatives have taken her house, and her husband is an orphan (the original reason her father objected to their marriage), when they are in a horrible accident, Anil is given responsibility for Sridevi and her unborn child. And then when Sridevi dies in childbirth, he blames the baby.
Not like he is mean to it! He gives Sridevi II (the baby) a wonderful childhood, raised by the same nanny who raised him, living in luxury in his palace in Rajasthan, he sends her gifts for every birthday and pays attention to her development, he just never lets himself meet her, or soften towards her in anyway. Until, finally, she is 18 and he meets her for the first time, to see that she looks exactly like Sridevi I.
But with key differences that are all to do with the brilliance of Sridevi as an actress, and how Yash Chopra supported it in his costume and set choices. Sridevi I always moved very calmly, slowly, with small smiles and delicate laughs. Sridevi II is brash and impetous, leaping around and warm and open in her smiles and laughter. Sridevi I wore saris and traditional make-up and jewelry. Sridevi II is very western, big permed hair, modern make-up, no saris.
(Until she falls in love, and cheerfully tries out the traditional look for the first time to please Anil)
And that is the plot of the second half of the movie, Anil slowly making peace with moving on from Sridevi I, and understanding that his love for Sridevi II is completely different. While the two women may look the same, that is all they have in common. It’s something everyone else sees before Anil. His nanny first of all, who raised Sridevi II and understands her, and sees that she is falling for Anil before she sees it herself. Anupum Kehr, Anil’s best friend who has been with him since he lost Sridevi II. And, most interestingly, Anil’s new girlfriend. Who is a lovely kind and classy woman, and who gently breaks their engagement and tells him he is in love with Sridevi II, even if he doesn’t see it. Again, Yash Chopra has the best female characters! Not in a big showy way, but in a quietly giving them their own motivation.
Another thing Yash Chopra always does is use a chronology that one of my friends described as making “emotional sense” rather than actually making sense on a calendar. So like in this, it feels like Anil spends a ton of time in Rajasthan, and then in almost no time after her marriage, Sridevi I is dead. And on a calendar, it really only makes sense to be a couple months at most in Rajasthan, and then at least a year if not longer that she is married. But emotionally, the time spent falling in love with Sridevi and getting to know his ancestral mansion would feel so much longer than the time spent in cold barren London trying to get over her, so that is how the sequences are edited, and it makes total sense to the viewer.
And then it is also yet another Yash Chopra love triangle film. He excels at these, and it is always the reasonable, mature love based on mutual interests, versus the passionate youthful love at first sight. What’s interesting is, he has a different ending movie to movie. In Silsila, he shows how the passionate love can be ultimately shallow and fade, but the love based on a shared life can deepen into a much stronger bond. And then in Chandni, he does the reverse, shows how the sensible mutual respect based love is ultimately much weaker than a passionate first love. I don’t think he keeps changing his mind about love film to film, I think it is that he is showing how, depending the particular personality of the characters he is showing and the way their love evolved, either answer could be correct.
In Lamhe, what I love is that he keeps mixing and matching the couples between passionate first love and reasoned older love. If you re-watch the first half, knowing that Sridevi I is nursing a broken heart and already completely committed to someone, it works perfectly. She is compassionate and kind toward Anil, but in the manner of a young married woman being kind to a young boy, not like a single woman flirting with him, which is how he takes it. Clearly, her love for her fiance began as a passionate kind of love that would lead her to go against her father’s wishes, but by this point it has become just a quiet understanding in the background of her life.
Meanwhile, Anil falls into passionate puppy love with her, the kind that will burn out eventually. That’s why she tells her husband that she doesn’t want to cut off contact, that it is better to stay in touch and let their relationship change naturally as the puppy love wears off. And then years later, Sridevi II falls into that same kind of passionate love with Anil, only in her case it doesn’t go away after more contact, and, like her mother, she ends up maturing from this first love feeling into heartbreak and commitment. But then the fascinating thing is, old Anil isn’t capable of that sort of crazy young love any more. So while Sridevi is completely in love with him very quickly, he has more of a slow coming to care for her kind of journey. Until they finally meet in the middle in the last scenes of the film.
Thanks for the post on Lamhe.. Thats great.. You got everything right.. It is one of my fav movies too..
I’m glad you liked it! I don’t usually get a lot of readers or comments for my posts on classic films, so I am thrilled to have someone enjoy it! If there is another movie you want me to cover, check out my To-Do list at the top of the screen. If it’s not there already, just request it in the comments and I will add it.
Hi, Lamhe is one of my all time favourite movies and I really enjoyed reading this deep analysis! I completely agree on how Yash Chopra movies have been “women oriented” in that they have had the most real, complex, multi dimensional characters in Hindi cinema. And Sridevi was the perfect vehicle for those characters in Chandni & Lamhe…I think it’s shocking how he let himself get distracted by a Katrina towards the end!
One point though – while the movie didn’t get box office success (which at that time depended more on small town & rural audiences), it won a lot of appreciation from city audiences & critics right from the day it released. In fact, it’s one of the few “flop” movies ever which won so many popular awards, including Filmfare.
That’s so interesting! Thanks for the box office info.
Pingback: My Movie To-Do List: Let Me Know If I Missed Something! And Click the Links to See What I Have Already Covered! | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Mouna Ragam: Embryonic Mani Ratnam | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Bhavum: My Favorite Character Actress Gets to be a Star | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Happy Birthday Yash Chopra Part 2! 32 through 55! | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Karan Flexes His International Muscles | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Happy Dear Zindagi Week! Jab Tak Hain Jaan, Shahrukh Deals With a Crush | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: 1 Year of Blogging!!! Which were my most successful posts? | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Hindi Film 101: The Chopras Part 3, Aditya Takes Charge, Gets Married, Has Baby – dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Happy Birthday Adi! I Will Let Your Work Speak For You – dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Silly Sunday Speculative Post: Pride Themed! (of course) Movies for LGBTQA&H! | dontcallitbollywood
Thank you for this Lamhe post. Just – thank you.
Lamhe is so beautiful. It’s one of those movies, like Pyaasa come to think of it, where a simple plot description does not come close to capturing how it feels. Yash Chopra was The Man back in the day. And then he lost his mind and made Jab Tak Hain Jaan.
On Mon, Jun 26, 2017 at 11:29 AM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:
Did you know that you and Karan are soul mates?
Awaara, Lamhe, Masoom – all on Karan’s top 10.
I will never stop being bitter about Jab Tak. Do you think our perception of the film would be different if it hadn’t been Katrina in that role? Like maybe Kajol? Or if Shah Rukh and the actress playing Meera had played their age?
I think if it had been a different actress it would have been a different movie. Kat was cast as this ethereal beauty, someone you could never quite grasp, floating through life. And because of the casting, I never got a sense of her character as anything more than that surface beauty. But, I think that’s kind of what Yashji wanted? Perfect magical love. If he had wanted something else, he would have cast someone else.
What feels so strange is that until the very end, it feels like the lesson of the movie is going to be “perfect magical love isn’t real, look for the reality not the fantasy”. And instead the lesson is “perfect magical love is something that will make you happy forever and ever.”
To compare it with Lamhe, this is the lesson he carefully avoided in his casting and his direction. Sridevi in the first half is clearly flawed, to the audience. But not to Anil. He sees the fantasy. By using Sridevi, Yashji cast an actress capable of being loving and charming, but also human, so we can see all sides. And then in the second half, we see how Sridevi 2 begins by seeing Anil as this perfect fantasy and slowly comes to see him as a human person with flaws and still loves him.
Or Chandni, the closer comparison, again all 3 leads have flaws. Sridevi is a bit too innocent when we first meet her and gains strength through adversity. Rishi has the more complicated journey, needing to “earn” back his love. Not through recovering form his illness, but by fully understanding that he can’t just toss her aside and expect her to come back to him. And Jackie had to let his heart open up again, and then understand that sometimes love means letting go.
And then there’s JTHJ, where no one ever changes or reveals any deeper layers. Or if they do (SRK and Anushka are too good actors to not put in some layers), those changes are thrown away because they don’t fit the narrative.
On Mon, Jun 26, 2017 at 11:39 AM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:
Lamhe is my fav Yash Chopra movie and his personal favorite too. His second favorite is Silsila. He calls these two movies his “rejected children”.
I reject that Adi had anything to do with this film because there are none of his cautious touches to the story. It is bold, passionate, reasoning Yash Chopra all the way.
Adi’s big change suggestion was to cut the post-interval part with child Sridevi, going straight to them meeting as adults. But then, the story would lose a bit of it’s challenge, wouldn’t it? The question of how much Sridevi was already conditioned to love Anil before she met him, how much her mother’s wishes that Anil would love again some day ended up somehow magically coming into her.
On Fri, Aug 25, 2017 at 2:41 PM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:
That’s interesting. I find it very difficult to believe but it’s possible.
Pingback: Jab Harry Met Sejal Scene By Scene Part 24: The Fight | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Friday Classics: I AM A DISCO DANCER!!!! (Mithunda Teaches Us How to Spell) | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Happy Birthday Yashji! 85 Reasons I Love You | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Happy Birthday Lataji! 88 Reasons I Love You, Part 2 | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Film Reviews | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Starter Kit: 7 Actresses in All 3 Phases of Their Career | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Friday Classic (on Saturday): Kabhi Kabhi, All Love is True Love | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Happy Birthday Anil Kapoor! 58 Years Young! | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Sridevi Film Reviews Index | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Chandni: Sridevi’s Most Beautiful Role | dontcallitbollywood