Monday Malayalam: Molly Aunty Rocks, The Middle-Aged NRI Woman Is Here to Save Us

Interesting movie.  Some of it I liked, some of it I didn’t, but most of all it had a middle aged working woman heroine going up against a young single guy antagonist!  Very odd combination, very satisfying.

I’ve been watching a lot of kind of weak movies that skated by on warm feelings for their aging stars.  This is one of the better films of that type, a good movie with interesting characters and little moments and all of that, but what makes it really unusual is that the aging star we have warm feelings for is a woman!!!!!  Revathy is 100% the lead of the movie, more than that, is 100% the whole movie! Prithviraj shows up eventually, but he doesn’t have nearly as much to do.  It’s Revathy’s show all along.

Image result for molly aunty rocks

I didn’t realize that I had already seen other movies by the same director, Ranjith Sankar, most recently Ramente Edenthottam.  If you had asked me cold to identify the director of this, or at least other films by him, I would have been stumped.  But looking at them as a group, I can see it.

Ranjith does a good job of showing characters who have learned, or are learning, not to care about the greater society if they feel like they are doing the right thing.  Not gangsters or political enforcers, not that kind of right thing.  Not even saintly doctors, or inspiring teachers.  Just people doing what they are doing as it comes in front of them, without thinking about anything else besides what is exactly in front of them.  Jayasurya in Punyalan Agarbattis had no shame in picking up elephant droppings and carrying them on his bike, because that was what made sense for him at the moment.  And Revathy here has no shame in talking back and talking loud about what she believes, even though she is a middle-aged woman, because that is what makes sense to her in the moment.  And often the villains are the ones who serve to represent that higher society, school teachers in Su…Su…Sudhi Vathmeekam, the temple committees in Punyalan Agarbattis, and in this film, the tax authorities.

What makes this film a little extra different is that our “hero” is a middle-aged difficult cheerfully determined woman, and the tax authority villain is the educated dedicated handsome young man that would be the hero in another film.

 

SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS

 

 

 

 

 

We come at Revathy sideways, through how other people see her.  Starting with her mother-in-law and family.  For them she is the odd one, the one their son married and they can’t understand why, the one who has mysteriously landed back in their lives after years living overseas.  And then it’s a bit of a surprise to see her arrive, this somewhat dowdy and flustered middle-aged woman.

I had to keep reminding myself not that this was the same Revathy as from her younger films, but that this was the same Revathy as 2 States in the same era.  In that film, a calm demeanor, beautiful saris, and a quiet voice made her the almost invisible gentle traditional mother.  In this film, pants and loose fitting shirts, a short hair cut, and big rapid flustered movements made her into a force of nature to be reckoned with, not quite fitting in with the south Indian world in which she found herself.  We can see why everyone immediately identifies her as American and why it is so strange to them that she came back.

Revathy gives a lot of reasons.  She says that she took leave from her bank job to get married, but has come back to finish out the last two years before her mandatory retirement so they can have the extra money for her daughters’ educations.  That she has to sell the little bit of family land for the same reason.  But it doesn’t quite make sense, because she is so clearly miserable and misfitting in India.

Not in the usual way of filmi NRIs.  Not complaining about the water or the food or unable to handle the bureaucracy.  She is fine with that, she has friends, she cooks, she speaks the language, she does well at her job.  It is the little things that itch at her, her friend’s shyness in exercising in public when men might be watching, not being able to part her car for 5 minutes to mail a letter, the bank not being able to think outside the box a little bit in order to better serve customers, for instance moving a teller over and splitting a long line into two.  She is someone who just doesn’t fit in India any more, can’t accept the rhythm of this way of life.  So, why is she there?

This film spends an inordinate amount of time in getting to the point.  It’s not exactly waste, we get to know fully just how much Revathy doesn’t fit in (for one thing, she keeps having to move house because she can’t seem to work with her landlords), and we get the backstory of her having a husband in America and her in-laws not approving of her and secretly selling the family land.  But it does go on a bit, so much that it is hard to notice when the actual plot picks up and starts.

Revathy gets a letter in the mail from the tax service.  She goes to ask about it, and the assistant at first puts her off, and then tries to get a bribe.  She refuses, reports him, and then gets another letter for a far larger amount.  She goes back to the office and finally meets the assistant collector, Prithviraj.  Who has no patience for her, explains that it is not a mistake, she failed to pay taxes for the salary she was getting, and for the land sale.  With 2 years of interest, this is the amount it has come to.

Everyone in her life has advice.  That she should somehow find the money and just pay it.  Or that she should just go back to America and forget about it, so long as she doesn’t return to India the case won’t matter.  But that’s not who she is.  She is someone who will keep arguing no matter what and not accept that there is the easy way out everyone else will take.

So her husband arrives, Lalu Alex, and they have one of the best moments of the film, a late night conversation in the bed room, not in bed, which makes it more “married” feeling to me, just the two of them sitting up talking with the lights out.  And we start to fully understand who Revathy is and why their marriage works like this.  After all his friends and family shaking their heads over her, Lalu Alex admits that he misses her, misses getting to clean up all the messes she causes, and she laughs at all the things she has put him through.  She is too old to change, she isn’t your usual youthful heroine who is going to learn a lesson and do better, she is who she is and she knows it and he knows it.

So they keep fighting, they hire an old advocate who helps them see their best argument.  They need a reason to claim that they should keep the money instead of giving it to the state.  Revathy had already given a speech about not minding paying taxes in America because she gets something for it, but why should she pay taxes in India when the whole country is falling apart?  The advocate suggests expanding on that.  Will the money really go to the poor of the country?  Why should they give it up just to go into the pockets of corrupt politicians?

And Prithviraj, the antagonist, is not looking great.  At first he was calm and reasonable, Revathy broke the law and he sent her a notice.  But after she sees him at her work and attacks him for trying to influence her boss, when in fact he was simply there on personal business, he is furious with her.  He is taking advice of his own, how he can put more and more pressure on Revathy up to and including taking her passport, and finally threatening jail for herself and her husband.

It’s a direct confrontation of the NRI attitude of “why can’t things be better?” and the Indian attitude of “what is the most I can do with the little I have?”  Prithviraj wants as much money as possible from Revathy however possible.  Revathy wants to improve the whole system within which Prithviraj lives.

And then we have our final reveal.  Done with sketches for flashback images, the 3rd of fourth time I have seen that in a Malayalam film.  I am sure it is a cheaper option, it’s also very artistically pleasing.  I wonder who did it first that everyone else is imitating?  In my life, the first time I can think of is Kill Bill Vol. 1, but that’s probably not what all the Malayalam films are picking up on.  For one thing, that came out 15 years ago and I am just seeing it in Malayalam films recently.

Anyway, the reveal is that Revathy wasn’t really trying to make money for her children’s education.  She and her husband were trying to fund an orphanage for victims of the 2004 Tsunami.  Inspired by the son of an old friend who was left orphaned, and Revathy sponsored him in an orphanage that ended up falling victim to a government scam and never being built, so Revathy decided to build it herself for him and all the other orphans similarly abandoned.  They school was almost built, but they never registered as a charity, never tracked the money that way, have no proof it was all donated.

Prithviraj learns a lesson about assumptions.  I appreciated that, that Prithviraj had thought she was this strong selfish independent stubborn woman and didn’t realize she was actually hiding a soft heart.  But then the audience learns the lesson about the importance of individual charitable giving untracked by any official channels, and that I did NOT appreciate.

The general idea is that you shouldn’t have to pay money towards the common good if you are already donating money towards the common good.  That’s why charitable deductions are standard in most country’s tax forms.  However, it is also standard that you need to track those donations and make them to officially recognized groups.  Because, you know, people lie!!!!!  This film seems to be arguing that we should just trust the good people because they are good and believe what they are saying.

What bothers me more is this larger message that it is not just up to the individual to fix social problems, but in fact it is BETTER for the individual to fix social problems.  Revathy and her husband are taking care of 50 orphans, fine.  But the government can take care of 50,000 orphans, if it is given the resources to do so.  And Revathy and her husband can build this orphanage on their own, fine.  But for long term sustainability, it is going to need a lot more people involved, and that’s why you register it as an official charity and hire professionals to run it and all the rest.

(Swades was different.  Because Shahrukh was really really really handsome.  No, it was because our hero actually fell in love with the village, and moved back.  He didn’t just complain and try to do a quick fix, he became Indian again himself and didn’t go home again.  He was one of them, not an outsider looking in.  And also really really handsome)

I see what the film is getting at, the same outside the box thinking that drove everyone crazy about Revathy is why she and her husband were willing and able to take this great leap and do this good thing.  Sometimes the people who seem the most difficult on the surface are the nicest underneath.  In the same way that cocky nemesis Prithviraj was in fact a little insecure and trying to prove himself.  I just wish it had found a better way to get there than implying that India should rely on NRIs to show up and magically solve all their problems and then run away back to America.  It is what I now think of as “Bharat Ane Nenu type thinking”.

Advertisements

12 thoughts on “Monday Malayalam: Molly Aunty Rocks, The Middle-Aged NRI Woman Is Here to Save Us

  1. `
    I’m not sure I could sit through it. I’ve always had problems keeping the audience in the dark and then a reveal that doesn’t really live up to the level it’s being presented as.

    `

    Like

    • The reveal in this case is sort of lame, so it doesn’t actually change everything that came before. Makes it a lot less of a “reveal” feeling.

      On Mon, Jul 30, 2018 at 10:53 PM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:

      >

      Like

  2. Okay, I don’t think you have got the structuring of Malayalam movies yet. Most movies don’t begin with the intend of concluding in a big final reveal. They generally begin with few characters or an interesting idea that is then developed into a story & somewhere towards the third act,a reason/incident is brought in to drive the film towards an audience-satisfactory end. Remember all those jerky ends in Priyadarshan films? This movie also follows a similar pattern. It is about the lady Molly & her experiences as an NRI in Kerala. -like how in Ustad Hotel it’s about food uniting generations. I don’t like the ‘reveals’ in both movies-the noble, honourable cause that forces the audience to side with some characters & show them in a ‘holier than thou’ light-it’s a clear manipulation. I won’t even go into the other messages that you mentioned like government v/s individual for social good or NRIs to the rescue. Those are just not the points. The intention of the finale reveal is to get few tears, give the characters a moral victory & then the audience can go home having experienced few laughs & cries-complete movie experience😃😃Most of the audience may not even remember the finale reveal, but would recollect the church scene confrontations between Molly & Prithviraj, the slimy tax official whom Molly first offends, the divorced church priest etc. My favourite is the one where Prithviraj sends Molly away after irritating the hell out of her & then settles with a big grin to order his tea & biscuits. He’s an official who’s supposed to work for the ppl & he’s enjoying doing the reverse.
    I think that was the other idea in the film-that beuroracy can really go after a citizen if they chooses to. Molly goes with a simpler problem but because she chooses to question/irritate the officials, they bring up bigger problems for her.Prithviraj’s character also has done a legal fraud which can be dug up by anyone(which Molly’s seemingly inefficient advocate does)who chooses to go after him. The babus in government offices enjoy their vast powers & bribes cos they can bend the law in any way. Most ppl succumb & chooses not to fight. But Molly being Molly is why the fight continues. And then they had to end the fight somehow by giving a plausible,(contrived in my opinion)worthy cause for Molly.
    I also love the relationship between Molly & her aged mom-in-law. We are so plagued with scheming MIL-daughter in law wars on TV, that these two women who are so different in their world-views, approaches, priorities etc can put aside the differences & live together peacefully. They do talk about her tax problems-so passes the Bechdel test I assume?
    I think this is a movie you may enjoy better if you don’t wait for the ‘big reveal’ or make the whole movie about the ending.The characters , their situations & reactions are closer to life than the ending itself.

    Like

    • It also may not have been helped that I had to watch this movie in two chunks separated by several days because of time constraints. It’s one of those films that, for me, I can remember moments I liked and characters I liked, but when I try to think of the whole thing together, somehow it just doesn’t gel.

      On Mon, Jul 30, 2018 at 11:38 PM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:

      >

      Like

  3. I LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS MOVIE!
    The Prithviraj cameo was so cute esp. the part where she tries to set him up with her daughter
    Whenever my mom goes to India for her yearly yoga vacations, most everyone would reference this movie and expect my reclusive to exhibit Molly’s behavior; it annoys her so much! They also assume I DATE! Jokes on them, my parents control every single aspect of my life
    Molly Aunty’s husband definitely is my Papa.
    So glad you watched it 🙂

    Like

    • I have heard that so much from the children of NRIs!!!! Everyone in India assumes they are running wild, but actually they are far more restricted than their Indian cousins. Ooo, fanfic idea? Good NRI goes back to India and her wild Indian cousins get her drunk and crazy?

      Like

      • I don’t care about being drunk to be free. In actuality, you are restricted.
        Just to learn to drive the car and motorcycle.
        It is considered an insult if a female drives in my fam if an able bodied Uncle is present to drive all us IN HIS OWN TIME.

        A young NRI girl who goes to India and FREEDOM! Basically Parvathy’s character in Charlie ❤

        Like

        • How about this? An NRI girl raised in a super protective American family, worried about her being corrupted and so forbidding her from socializing outside of community events, making her speak Hindi at home, keeping her away from people her own age, and so on and so on. She is sent to India for 3 months to keep her “safe” while her parents have to travel for work or something. But there is a mix-up, her aunt and uncle that she was supposed to be staying with are traveling too, so she ends up landing with her slightly older cousin who has her own apartment and everything and the two girls alone in India are more free than our NRI heroine was living with her parents in America.

          Or, different option, she stays with her male cousin (or maybe a friend of her cousin who is housesitting at her aunt and uncle’s when she shows up on their doorstep) who starts out by feeling kind of sorry for her and helping her to find herself, kind of like Nivin in Mili. But then in the second half, she has turned awesome and confident and outgoing and started dating one of his friends and now he has FEELINGS for her and it all gets terribly complicated.

          Like

          • Male cousins are sooooo out of the picture esp. if you are of mariagable age (21-24). My parents would literally fly out themselves and put me in their safe house than me spending time with my cousins.

            I was thinking more like, being with her rebellious grandmother, who is all about to letting her granddaughter have freedom because she knows that life sucks having lived that life herself as well as raised her children with the same principles.
            Kinda like Oru Muthasi Gadha. Have you seen it?

            Like

          • Yes! With the Grandma roping the boyfriend into things, and realizing he is just a harmless scared boy and nothing bad is happening. I loved that part of the movie, Grandma and teen granddaughter bonding.

            What about a miss-communication, rest of the family is gone, it turns out to be just Grandma and NRI granddaughter, and Grandma’s nurse/home helper is a local girl who is a few years older and living on her own and has cool relaxed parents and it shows how the NRI is more protected than the local just depending on who their parents are. Maybe all NRI granddaughter wants at first is to learn to drive a scooter like the nurse does, but it snowballs from there, she gets more and more independent and happy and it ends with her telling her parents that she wants to stay in India and go to school there and be roommates with the nurse/home helper. Heck, maybe Grandma breaks free too! Says she wants to move in with the nurse/granddaughter and cook for them and take care of them because they need and respect her, unlike her son’s family who doesn’t really care any more.

            Of course, then we don’t have a romance, and I always want a romance.

            Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.