Shahrukh Discussion Question: If You Can Only Pick One, Which Iconic Detective/Action Hero Should He Play?

It’s been a while since we talked SRK, he’s probably feeling bad about that. Let’s cheer him up! Let’s have a silly fan conversation about characters he could play!


Rumpled average man in an old raincoat, cleverly beating out the rich and famous murderers and charming the innocent victims he champions.

TGIF: Women Objectifying Men | dontcallitbollywood

James Bond

James Bond! Tuxedo, seduction, cool violence.

Pin by Ishawar Lalchand on tuxedo | Shahrukh khan, Khan, Bollywood


Batman! Rich, but tormented, and a little bit crazy.

Shahrukh Khan's Leather Jacket (All Collection) | RAVEN

The Saint

A mysterious gentleman criminal who steals from the rich and solves murders for the poor.

Shahrukh Khan In 10 Lakh Armani Suit At Deepika Ranveer Reception Party In  Mumbai - YouTube

Charlie Chan (but South Asian)

A family man often dismissed by the majority thanks to his membership in a minority group, but ultimately earns their respect through his intelligence and self-assurance.

Shah Rukh Khan appears on David Letterman's Netflix show, shares first pic  on social media - Television News

Inspector Morse

Weary, older, cynical on the outside and a dreamer on the inside. Always falling in love with the wrong people.

Farah Khan has a good idea for 'Main Hoon Na 2'

Father Brown

Kind, warm, wise, simple and brilliant at the same time.

Shahrukh Khan and Alia Bhatt | Alia bhatt, Bollywood celebrities, Bollywood  actress

Indiana Jones

A scholar and an adventurer, always with a clever quip and a wry smile.

Major Samar Anand in Jab Tak Hai Jaan | Shahrukh khan, Shah rukh khan  movies, Bollywood actors

I was thinking Columbo, that kind of everyman vibe would be so good, but now I have fallen in love with the idea of Charlie Chan!!! The original Charlie Chan books (not the later movies with yellow face and stuff) take place in Hawaii and San Francisco in the 20s and 30s, an era when the central Asian community was still dealing with a lot of prejudice. The author actually went out on a limb a bit to have this detective who is calm and polite and puts up with all the insults he gets, and then fearlessly solves the murder and arrests the criminal. Heck, he went out on a limb by having Charlie Chan be a Hawaiian police officer, an American citizen, not an “outsider” at all except in the minds of small minded (usually murderer) people.

Anyway, I want Shahrukh to be a calm South Asian heritage Muslim American who has a large family and a house (not some transitory outsider, but someone fully living the American dream) and rose up through the ranks of the police force, and calmly deals with prejudice and ignorance without letting it defeat him, until the moment he gets to formally arrest some rich white idiot. And also isn’t afraid to refer back to his moral grounding as a Muslim while talking to suspects (“the Koran says…”).

America Needs to Offer More 'Warmth': Shah Rukh

10 thoughts on “Shahrukh Discussion Question: If You Can Only Pick One, Which Iconic Detective/Action Hero Should He Play?

  1. Batman! Of course Batman. Tortured, sexy and dark. Just up his alley.

    I’m not into religious stuff and prefer not to be clobbered with it. So nay on that.


  2. I hear you on Charlie Chan but gotta go with Columbo. He’d have to do a slightly different take, I don’t think he could play dumb (not dumb exactly but you know what I mean, Columbo comes off initially as not the brightest). But distracted and accidentally charming until it’s too late and you realize he’s figured it all out…that would be fun to watch.


    • Yes! Maybe a little shallow? Like always fixing his hair and stuff so the murderers dismiss him as a slightly vain silly fellow?

      On Fri, Jan 15, 2021 at 12:48 AM dontcallitbollywood wrote:



      • Yes, exactly. Vain, distracted, unserious. Until he suddenly looks up from under his eyebrows with that gaze that cuts straight through.


        • Or those little moments when he sincerely feels bad for an innocent victim and turns gentle and kind.

          On Fri, Jan 15, 2021 at 8:02 AM dontcallitbollywood wrote:



  3. I don’t know everyone of those heroes, but I could totally see SRK as Indiana Jones. Not young, but totally making college girls swoon. An adventurer through and through. And then Amitabh plays Senior Jones.


  4. I’d also say Charlie Chan based on him being one of the few people in the hindi film industry who actually is intelligent. He was also an outsider and a minority in the industry at one point in time.
    Although, I don’t think for a detective role he himself or anyone else for that matter can ever top his Badshah. ^_^ 😀


    • His Baadshah was for the ages!!! I don’t think Charlie Chan even had a theme song 🙂

      And yaaaay, another Charlie Chan vote! I agree, the intelligent outsider minority who is better than everyone else is a great fit for him.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.