Quick Speculative May The Fourth Post

Obviously, today is Star Wars day.  And also a day when I am super busy at work and can’t really focus.  But I can do a “speculative” post without any problems!  I get so caught up in my little imaginary worlds, that nothing can shake me.  So, let’s do a mini Star Wars fest! (updated version of this post here)

No need to worry about the plot, we just take the original trilogy, smash it into one three hour plus film.  Get rid of the sci-fi stuff, because I don’t think that works as well in India.  Make it fantastical instead, Bahubali style.  Otherwise, same-to-same.  Luke is a lost warrior raised on a farm, Leia is his secret sister, Obi Wan Kenobi is his mentor, Han Solo is a smuggler, Darth Vader is evil, plot happens.

Casting, that’s where we can have the debates!  And this is such a timeless story, I really feel like it would work in any era.  So let’s do it decade by decade!



Luke: Dilip Kumar (has a kind of innocent demeanor, good with a sword)

Image result for dilip kumar young

Leia: Nargis (Classy, confident, powerful)

Image result for nargis young

Han Solo: Dev Anand (cool kind of bad boy vibe)

Image result for dev anand

OR Raj Kapoor (crazy chemistry with Nargis, could also be bad when he wanted to, their swimsuit scene in Awara is basically a Leia-Han scene already)

Image result for awara nargis

Obi Wan: Ashok Kumar (older, wise, had a real life mentor relationship with Dilip)

Image result for ashok kumar dilip kumar

Darth Vader: Prithviraj Kapoor (Screen presence like you wouldn’t believe!  Plus, very tall.  And a great voice)

Image result for prithviraj kapoor



Luke: Rajesh Khanna (Young Rajesh Khanna would make the sexiest innocent farm boy ever!)

Image result for rajesh khanna young

Leia: Sharmila Tagore (Confident, cool, able to give back as much as she got)

Image result for sharmila tagore

Han Solo: Shammi Kapoor (he just doesn’t care about anything!)

Image result for shammi kapoor

Obi Wan: Ashok Kumar (still totally able to pull it off well into the 60s)

Image result for ashok kumar rajesh khanna

Darth Vader: Pran (he can play anything)

Image result for pran



Luke: Amitabh (not even going to bother explaining, this casting is so clearly right)

Leia: Hema Malini (ditto)

Han Solo: Dharmendra (ditto)

Image result for amitabh hema malini dharmendra

Obi Wan: Pran! (he can still play anything)


Image result for pran 1970s

Darth Vader: Sanjeev Kumar (he can play anything too)

Image result for sanjeev kumar




Luke: Anil Kapoor (It’s Anil Kapoor!  How could you not?)

Image result for young anil kapoor

Leia: Dimple (Mature, confident, very cool)

Han Solo: Sunny Deol (cool, strong, great chemistry with Dimple)

Image result for dimple kapadia sunny deol

Obi Wan: Shammi Kapoor (doing character roles in his older years, couldn’t move very well, but still had such great presence!)

Image result for shammi kapoor

Darth Vader: Danny Danzongpa (it’s the 80s, it’s always Danny Danzongpa)

Related image



Luke: Salman Khan (Salman in Maine Pyar Kiya mode is a perfect Luke)

Image result for salman khan maine pyar kiya

Leia: Sridevi (I was going to put her in the 80s until I remembered Dimple, but she was still acting in the 90s, so this works)

Image result for sridevi

Han Solo: Anil Kapoor (I’m open to suggestions, but he had such great chemistry with Sridevi, and he was kind of in a Tapoori bad boy mode in the 90s)

Image result for anil kapoor sridevi

Obi Wan: Anupum Kher! The perfect Obi Wan!

Image result for anupam kher anil kapoor

Darth Vader: Amrish Puri!  The perfect Darth Vader!  This may be my favorite cast

Image result for amrish puri



Luke: Hrithik

Leia: Priety Zinta

Image result for hrithik preity zinta

Han Solo: Shahrukh

Related image

Obi Wan: Amitabh

Image result for amitabh hrithik

Darth Vader: Amitabh in a clever double role!

Image result for amitabh hrithik


And finally, 2010s:

Luke: Ranbir Kapoor

Image result for ranbir kapoor wake up sid

Leia: Kareena Kapoor (clever, right?)

Image result for ranbir kapoor kareena kapoor

Han Solo: Ranveer Singh maybe?

Image result for ranveer singh

Obi Wan: Shahrukh

Image result for shahrukh khan dear zIndagi

Darth Vader: Amitabh!

Image result for amitabh ranbir kapoor


So, comments?  Questions?  Disagreements?  Complaints that this is a very silly and lightweight post?  I welcome them all!


17 thoughts on “Quick Speculative May The Fourth Post

  1. This photo of Shammi Kapoor is so Han Solo! you couldn’t find better one.
    I love 60′ and 90′ casts. I’m not sure about 2000 (Hrithik is too handsome for playing Luke)and 2010 ones (I’m not fan of Kareena and Ranbir)


    • I was tempted to suggest Saif for 2000s Luke, but he seems too old. Oh! What about Akshaye Khanna?

      On Thu, May 4, 2017 at 4:15 PM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:



      • It’s been a year now since I watched Taal, but I still suffer post-Taal trauma and just can’t stand Akshaye. But I found better guy to play Luke: Abhishek Bachchan. He was young in 2000 and, the most important Amitabh would play Darth Vader, and I found it perfect. What do you think?


    • Oh wow, you are right! I was thinking Varun for Han actually, but he was too old.

      Okay, this changes everything. Varun for Luke, who for Han? Ranveer still? Or maybe Arjun Kapoor?

      And then Leia could be Alia.

      On Thu, May 4, 2017 at 4:32 PM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:



  2. Finally something where i can actually comment apart ftom monday questions and wednesday reviews.

    I dont agree with you thay sci fi cant be made or people wont like it. First star wars wasnt too high on special effects. It was also not very good. EMPire strikes back created everything we like about Star wars.

    Following should be cast for Star wars

    Luke: Ranbir kapoor. He looks like Luke. He can portray yoing coming of age person

    Leia: Alia Bhatt. She is a good actor and has looks to pass as Liea

    Han Solo: Diljit. Han solo is han soloish character. He is rogue, rough. Han solo woild have to be funnier. I think Diljit can play rogueness of Han but with some goofiness.

    Obi Wan: Amitabh Bacchan. I dony need to explain anything about it

    Darth Vader: Sanjay Dutt’s voice. It has to be dominating

    General Tarkin: Paresh Rawal

    Emperor palpatine: Boman Irani


    • That is a great cast! My only concern is if Alia and Ranbir would be believable as twins. But otherwise, perfect!

      Oh, if not Alia, maybe Anushka?


      • Thanks for the compliment
        Anushka will be good too. Although she will look older.
        I was about to put the name of a south Indian actor but I dont remember the name. I was watching a south Indian movie some days back. Its hero would have been perfect but i dont remember the name of anything.


  3. One question

    If you are a fan of star wars, why havent you seen force awakens and rogue one and are not excited about The Last Jedi?


    • I have seen The Force Awakens, I have a post about it somewhere in the archives.

      But I’m not a fan of Star Wars, I just know about it and enjoy the movies. But it’s not a big part of my life.

      On Thu, May 4, 2017 at 8:32 PM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:



      • Sorry, by seeing this post i assumed you to be a star wars fan. I was also surprised while assuming this
        Is your review of The force awakens positive?


        • Yes, with reservations. The plot could have been a little more imaginative. But I really liked the way they used the older characters and older actors instead of trying to start entirely new.

          On Thu, May 4, 2017 at 8:51 PM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:



          • Prequels tried to be more imaginative.
            I liked the simplicity. I also liked the fact that Rey wasnt whiny as Luke and didnt have to go through long process of ttaining before any sort of offence.
            It kept things simple. It was better than New hope.


          • Are there Hollywood action movies that you like without any reservations?


          • Sure! Die Hard, Lethal Weapon, Rocky movies (if you consider them action films). Oh, and John Wick, both films, are terribly terribly brilliant.

            On Thu, May 4, 2017 at 9:03 PM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:



          • You do have goodish taste in action movies.
            I dont consider Rocky as action movies though.
            I prefer Rambo and terminator over Lethal weapon.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.