If this is the kind of movie you like, you will like this movie. It was never going to be great realistic drama, it was always going to be light and fluffy. But if you are capable of enjoying light and fluffy films, this is one of the better ones.
I went into this knowing that it would be a light silly movie about light silly things. And it was! But at the same time, it was also a much better movie than I expected. The plot took some twists that weren’t obvious, the actors were legitimately entertaining (I’m not saying great performances, but then it didn’t require great performances), the songs were great, and there was Will Smith! I’m not saying everybody should watch it, but if you enjoyed 2 States, or I Hate Luv Storys, or Mujshe Dosti Karoge, or (of course) Student of the Year 1, you will like this movie. It is a good example of the genre to which it belongs.
There’s loads of things I could make fun of with this movie, but then they aren’t trying to NOT have us make fun of them. It’s like when I wear a bright orange skirt with a bright purple top and a big pink hat. If someone says “ha-ha, you are wearing many bright colors together”, I will go “yes, and….?” because obviously I did that on purpose because I like bright colors together.
Tiger and Aditya Seal are obviously way too old to go to high school, but so what? The filmmakers know that, we know that, they want the audience to see hunky men with developed muscles and superior fight scenes so they bend reality. The love stories are simple and superficial, everyone is aware, but they wanted a strong simple storyline so that the details of the romance wouldn’t overwhelm the rest of it. And the acting is over the top and stylized, but again, that’s the idea. This is the kind of acting, and kind of characters, that I can picture small children and middle-schoolers acting out after the movie, debating which “team” they are on over school lunches, basically the animated fairy tale version of a plot and a performance. Heck, Kabaddi is the big important all consuming sport for this exclusive high school, that’s also hilarious, but who cares? This is a movie for an Indian audience and they wanted a simple game the audience would all know, plus Kabaddi is a fun sport to film, plus it let them experiment with weird wrestling moves and leaps and spins. All the silly stuff is there for a purpose, to help us enjoy the movie more.
And I did enjoy the movie! I really really did! There was nothing in it that made me go “ouch, that’s a rough spot”. The heroines each did a good job, as good as Tiger and Aditya Seal. And yes, the acting requirements were dumbed down for them all, but with what they were given, they did good. Ananya especially, her character has a lot of the best lines, and she nailed them. Not that they were that deep, or even that good lines, but she said them well, she put in the work and she cared about it. And she does have a spark onscreen, it’s true. Tara Sutaria was good too, she had less dialogue which made her character harder to capture, but she struggled along with face acting okay. And Tiger was not asked to go any farther than he could manage, he has a natural charisma onscreen that can cover a lot of sins, plus of course his dancing ability and fight scenes. The plot was very tight and clear, the characters got layers and depth in an appropriate speed and manner, everything made sense with no awkward leaps and jitters. The costumes were ridiculous but fun, so were the sets, so were the performances around the three leads too. Everything was set to 11 (as it were) in a very conscious and entertaining way.
To give you an example of the “11” setting, everywhere on the St. Teresa’s campus, literally everywhere, you see the name “St. Teresa’s”. They must have told the set designers to go over the top with it, make it look like a designer label on clothing kind of thing. It goes beyond “ha-ha, they’re so stupid” and into the realm of “no, they are being stupid-clever”. Along the same lines, all the cheerleaders at St. Teresa’s are white. Again, it’s ridiculous, but it’s also over the line into “we don’t care, these aren’t really cheerleaders for an Indian high school, these are sexy white women for our silly movie and everyone knows it”. If they hadn’t turned it up like that, the movie as a whole wouldn’t have worked as well. We need all the silliness to make us able to enjoy the simple plot at the center of it, the fun dance numbers, all the rest.
The one flaw, for me, is that Ananya’s character falls into a the sort of “Poo” dynamic that I think Indian returns to too much when they are trying to do a “sexy saucy young woman” character. Preity in Kabhi Alvida Na Kehna, Alia in SOTY 1, Kareena in Mujshe Dosti Karoge, it’s like being just nasty to everyone is empowering and “cool”. This film gives a background for it and redeems her character, but I still feel like they thought I would enjoy her nastiness, yelling at people and playing mean pranks, in a way that I just didn’t. On the other hand, the film also never punishes her for her behavior and (most importantly), the hero never “cures” her of it.
Tara’s character gets slightly short shrift, but that feels less like Ananya getting an outsize role and more like last minute editing. Tara gets a decent amount of time in the first half and has a solid character arch, a really interesting one. But the second half in general feels like they slashed scenes. Ananya’s part is more important in the second half so they had to give her more time, but Tara goes down to the bare minimum. They even cut the wedding song, “Mumbai Dilli Di Kudiyan”, which would have done a lot of development for both Tara and Ananya’s storylines at that point. It must have been a last minute cut, because they left in a scene setting it up (a character gives Tiger a card for his wedding), and then no song.
That’s maybe the roughest bit of the film, that the resolution on their stories feels a little rushed as though one or two scenes were removed. But if you make a movie and the worst bit, the only bit that doesn’t quite work, is a few sped up developments towards the finale, that is still a really solid film.
That’s what this movie is, solid. Good direction, good editing, competent performances, fun set design and costume design, catchy songs, and a script with absolutely no gaps or holes in the plot. There may be other films with high ambitions, greater talents involved, and so on. But there is nothing to be ashamed of in making a good solid little film that achieves it’s goals, and nothing to be ashamed of in enjoying it either.
YES!!!!! He has a series called “Bucket List” and one episode was about wanting to be in an Indian movie. I’m sure Dharma was THRILLED. It’s a fun cameo, he comes out for 20 seconds and does the little dance move with the leads in the middle of the “Yeh Jawaani” song.
Will Smith in the Jawaani song!?
This just gets more unexpected
I like the romance plot that you have described about the movie. I’m thinking if they had called the movie as Pyar,Pyar Pyar or I Luv Love Stories or anything other than Student of The Year 2,ppl may not have really known what to expect and probably would have been more kind to the movie. By choosing a title that ties the movie to a specific template of how it looks and feels,how it’s characters are going to be & a plot where the love story that you described isn’t really the center conflict,it feels more like an excuse to set the bar/goals really low & make some quick bucks like a Baagi2. I hope this movie fails so that a Student3 with even lesser goals is not made.
Also,how does this movie fare in comparison with the first movie in this franchise?
It’s less original in terms of style, the first one did something really new with the kind of heightened cartoonish awareness of the setting. But I think the basic plot might be better, the first one was a little bit all over the place with too many stories going on. This one keeps it simple and focused on Tiger’s character, his experiences and motivations and romances.
Remember with Kalank how I felt like the script needed a few more rewrites, it just didn’t quite hold together yet and the actors didn’t really know what they were supposed to be doing? This movie is the opposite of that, the script is so tight that the actors could just show up and say their lines and the film would work. Even more so than in SOTY. That’s impressive. The scriptwriter is going to be directing his first movie soon and I am excited to see what he comes up with.
On Sat, May 11, 2019 at 8:09 AM dontcallitbollywood wrote:
It’s a really solid plot, and I could see it working even in a film with a different style and setting. Baaghi is an interesting comparison, because both Baaghi 1 and 2 were remakes of southern films with very different flavors. They took the essential solid plot and reworked it to be lighter and more action-y and more Tiger-y. I don’t think this plot is a remake, but I could imagine the same basic idea being used for, for instance, a more adult love story set in a work environment (Tiger gets hired at the agency where his college sweetheart is working and hates the bosses daughter who is nasty to him). the plot itself doesn’t make it a SOTY film, it’s the style with which it is presented.
On Sat, May 11, 2019 at 4:12 AM dontcallitbollywood wrote:
It sounds better than I would have expected but I probably wouldn’t watch it because I prefer more mature kind of romances
But one thing, preity’s character in Kank wasn’t like that right? She was independent and maybe a little sassy but still a polite and mature woman. I think maybe Sanjana in Main Hoon Na? Amrita Rao’s character? I think her name was Sanjana lol but who knows. But she was unnecessarily rude and brash
Preity’s character was a little bit like that. At least her work scenes were a little about her being extra snappy and confident and fun in a way that felt slightly exagerrated to me. But you are so right, Sanjana in Main Hoon Na is another good example. At least with her the “secret love for Zayed” was introduced early on so we saw she wasn’t just horrible for the sake of being horrible. They even dress Ananya in this like Amrita in that, tight pants and short tops.
And yes, you are wise to stay away. But I predict comments/reviews from people who are less wise than you and say “I didn’t like this movie! It was so silly and immature!” instead of just not watching it because they should have been able to tell they wouldn’t like it.
On Sat, May 11, 2019 at 12:05 PM dontcallitbollywood wrote: