Dear Comrade Review (No Spoilers): A Lovely Illogical Romance

I did it! A midweek movie! At a theater that doesn’t usually show Indian movies, and was still half full on a Thursday. So, woo-hoo Vijay Devaronda!!!! His career is growing by leaps and bounds.

Do you like romances? Do you like swoony moments and tormented heroes and lovable average heroines? Then this is the movie for you! On the other hand, if you like tightly crafted logical plots, this is NOT the movie for you. Go away and watch some other movie and leave us illogical romance lovers alone.

Image result for dear comrade poster

Vijay is wonderful, and the role is clearly written for him. It’s a bit of an Arjun Reddy redux. Less raw and brilliant, more just hitting the same notes of sweet unexpected love, followed by torment, followed by personal growth. The heroine was surprisingly charming, both her performance and how her character was written and presented. I hadn’t seen Rashmika Mandanna in anything else, but that is my own fault. She was in Geetha Govindam with Vijay just last year, and she was in the Kannada hit Kirik Party, and she was in Devadas with Nagarjuna and Nani. All movies that I intended to getting around to watching someday, and have not. Her performance in this film, and her chemistry with Vijay, was a delightful surprise to me only because of my willful ignorance of her previous work. On the other hand, surprises are nice! I went in knowing Vijay was the hero, but not even sure who the heroine character was until long after her introduction, so their romance was as much a surprise to me as to the characters.

This is a first time director movie, and it’s not bad for a first time director. As I said, the plot is a bit rocky, I kept itching to rewrite it. But the visuals are great, and the individual scenes are lovely, and the characters and performances that develop are a tribute to the skill of a director willing to take his time and bring out the best. Bharat Kanna’s next film could be perfected and wonderful, or he could sink into obscurity. But I’m gonna be optimistic! There are the seeds of some really wonderful things in this movie that could grow and grow over a few more films.

This is kind of an interesting film in that it has pretenses to be an Arjun Reddy, but it is really far more of a Sekhar Kammula film. A slow story that builds in multiple characters, a romance with a heroine who has more problems and strength inside than the hero, and a larger message of good people doing good things and being rewarded. Maybe that is why the plot ended up so confused? It was trying to serve two masters, the sweet stable sensitive Telugu film tradition and also the new age rough and tumble realistic Telugu hero.

There’s even the classic preparing for a family wedding sequence! It’s totally a friendly family film, dressed up in dark anti-hero clothing.

But none of that relates to the main reason for this review, should you watch it? As a romance, it has all the best ingredients. Multiple delicious romantic moments, great songs, great central characters with a believable love story. As a movie with a message (which it has pretensions to be), it doesn’t work very well. As a movie about Communism, it completely loses the thread halfway through. As a movie about feminism…well, that’s interesting. It fails in the message it intends to give, but it succeeds in the feminist message that all great romances have, a strong interesting individual who happens to be a woman falling in love with another strong interesting individual who happens to be a man.

7 thoughts on “Dear Comrade Review (No Spoilers): A Lovely Illogical Romance

  1. So seeing the way you are fumbling on the feminist theme,I am assuming the movie is about the hero’s journey and the heroine and romance are plot devices that aids it.Or is it really about the heroine or even an equal space journey of the couple,in which case the comparison with Sekhar Kammula would hold fort.But seeing how this movie was marketed as a Vijay Devarakonda film,I am less inclined to think so.Do correct me if I am wrong in my presumption.
    The director had mentioned in an interview that he originally thought of SaiPallavi as the heroine,but Vijay Devarakonda wanted Rashmika.They later did damage control by saying that SaiPallavi was not okay with the kissing scenes and hence backed out.I wasn’t impressed with Rashmika in Geetha Govindam or Kiraak Party,so have to see if she does more than making funny,sad faces as acting.
    Now that you have seen it,who do you think KJo will cast in the remake?Janhvi and Vicky?

    Like

    • It’s such a mess in construction!!!! It should be equally Vijay and Rashmika’s story, in terms of actual things that happen to their characters and things their characters do, they have equal movement. But because it had to be promoted as a Vijay movie, they inserted a bunch of fight scenes and songs that give him more screentime than really makes sense and kind of weirdly unbalanced it.

      there is a very surprising plot point late in the film which is explicitly feminist, to the point of the movie ending with one of those two minute speeches to reporters about the problems of society. That’s what I think was supposed to be the feminist part, but it landed weirdly for me, and I much preferred the way the rest of the film was constructed with a strong outspoken sure of herself heroine. And I can’t really dig into why it was weird and didn’t work because I don’t want to spoil the plot point, which makes this review very hard to write.

      On Thu, Jul 25, 2019 at 11:22 PM dontcallitbollywood wrote:

      >

      Like

  2. I’ve been looking forward to seeing this one so I’m glad to hear it was decidedly not terrible, even if imperfect. I’ll read the review with spoilers after I see it this weekend!

    Like

  3. Geetha Govindam was a huge hit but I wouldn’t recommend you seeing it because I’m very confident in thinking that you would hate it. It’s basically a problematic plot packaged in a movie with comedy, colorful songs, cute people. I enjoyed the movie while watching it but I felt really uncomfortable about it afterwards.

    Like

Leave a reply to MKP Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.