NRI Week: The Soiled NRI Woman, Purab Aur Paschim, DDLJ, Befikre, and My Name is Khan

Another common NRI trope! I was thinking these films didn’t fit because the hero is still desi, and then I realized it only doesn’t fit if I consider the national identity as residing in the man. It doesn’t of course, a woman can just as easily be an NRI.

Let’s start with DDLJ. What was revolutionary about DDLJ was that the hero was an NRI. Not just an Indian studying overseas, but British born and raised. That’s very important for Shahrukh’s character, but it is perhaps even more revolutionary for Kajol’s character.

There have been many many MANY NRI heroines before. The prototypical one is Saira Banu from Parab Aur Paschim. She is ruined by the West, has lost touch with her Indian roots, is sexually loose, appears “white” in her make-up and clothes, and disrespects her parents. And has no knowledge of or value for her culture. And then the nice hero arrives from India and teaches her how to be Indian again, saves her and restores her to her natural “Indian” setting. And brings her back home to India.

Image result for saira banu purab aur paschim
Pretend this is an evil disgusting westernized woman, and not a SUPER COOL 60s look that you want to steal. I mean, that hair! Those eyes! The beads!

This is a fantasy of the actual NRI woman, while Kajol in DDLJ provided the reality. An NRI woman, if she is truly spoiled by the west, will not return to her default setting of “Indian”. Because that isn’t her default setting, she is British or Polish or Canadian or whatever else. The changes are not mere superficialities of hair and make-up, they are deep inside her soul. And on the other hand, often those changes don’t even appear as superficialities. Merely raising your child overseas does not mean she will not know Indian culture, inherit Indian modesty, and so on and so forth. But it might mean that she has a different way of thinking about the world which is hidden deep inside where you cannot reach. That is the NRI woman we see in Kajol in DDLJ, and in her filmi descendants. She loves her parents, she knows her Indian traditions, but somewhere deep inside she wants to marry for love, she wants to travel through Europe, she wants to enjoy all the freedoms that all her non-desi friends have. And she does NOT want to go back to India.

It all goes back to the national identity residing within the woman. If an “Indian” woman is not truly Indian, down deep where it counts, than is there any nation at all, any firm identity? The NRI woman must have her surface scrapped away, must be worn down and forced to reveal her true “Indian” nature. And so the idea of an “NRI woman” ceases to exist, she is merely an Indian woman waiting to be revealed.

Saira, fixed.

But at the same time, we do get to see that surface. Again, we go back to Purab Aur Paschim. Our hero Manoj Kumar has a girl in love with him back home, Bharathi Vishnuvardhan. She is the perfect Indian girl, traditional and sweet and loyal and modest and patriotic. Manoj goes to London for studies and stays with an old friend of the family and meets his daughter, Saira Banu. She wears short skirts and a blond wig and heavy eye shadow, she drinks and smokes, she is “bad”. But it is Saira who Manoj has the love affair with. And once she asks about marriage, he forces her to come back to India and breaks her down until she reveals her “Indian” heart. Essentially, until she transitions into Bharathi, the girl he rejected. But if he ends up with a girl like Bharathi after all, what was the point of rejecting her to begin with in preference for Saira? Or, put it another way, if his end goal was to change everything about Saira, why did he even want her to begin with?

It’s the challenge, it’s “conquering” the West through conquering this woman who represents it. A white woman character in a film can serve the same purpose, but then would bring up questions as to our hero’s identity as an Indian man. In these films, the Indian woman has turned Western. Our proper Indian hero is given control of her through proper Indian channels (family connections and so on). And then, without risking his identity as a good Indian boy, he can go on to tame the West, capture and control it.

This is the story of Hrithik and Kareena in K3G, of Akshay and Katrina in Namaste London, of innumerable other films. But then there are the exceptions, the ones that push back, that say “no, being an NRI is not an identity a woman can shake off like a cloak, and it is nothing that makes her worse than you.”

British Katrina, cured by Indian Akshay

Aditya Chopra started to question this idea with DDLJ, making our heroine not “soiled” by the West but merely existing within it, and letting her and the hero meet each other as equals, neither conquering the other or converting the other. And then in his light farce Befikre, hidden deep inside, he directly confronted it. Befikre begins as your standard NRI Woman-Indian hero kind of story. Our hero arrives from India and meets his French-Indian heroine that same day. They fall into a relationship, her parents love him and approve, she was previously sexually free and casual but after getting together with him becomes monogamous. It is the standard beats of our good upstanding (sexually inexperienced) Indian hero fixing our broken NRI heroine.

But then they break up. And during the final fight, he throws in her face that she slept around before she was with him. And she leaves, too hurt to stay. Over the next year, he has his own experiments with casual sex, and she seriously dates someone else. They finally come together and have an honest conversation in which he acknowledges that he was wrong to make her feel guilty for having other relationships, that was his problem not hers. This is a story of growth, this is a story of the reality of cross-cultural overseas relationships. Ranveer, our hero, is living in France. It is up to him to adjust to French standards, not Vaani to adjust to his Indian standards. Not only that, hidden within Vaani’s performance and character, is guilt because she is not so confident in her French identity, Ranveer’s accusation really did hurt her. She responds by trying to become “Indian”, go through that journey of every other NRI film heroine, date a nice Indian man, have a respectable marriage and engagement, and so on and so forth. But that’s not the answer. The answer is for her and Ranveer to jointly accept their identity as both Indian and French, for him to leave behind his casual sex shallow easy relationship with a white woman and her to leave her quick serious marriage relationship with an Indian man, and find a middle ground together.

That is the answer for all of these NRI women. To simply accept who they are and expect those around it to accept it too. They are not some perfect Indian woman waiting to be discovered, they are NRIs, and that identity is as secure on them and within them as it would be within a male character. A woman’s identity isn’t controlled by her father, or her future husband, but by the whole society around her.

There’s another Shahrukh-Kajol film that also doesn’t get much attention for the NRI heroine element, My Name is Khan. Setting aside the tragic horrible elements of it and focusing solely on Kajol’s character, this is what a female NRI looks like. She came to America as an adult, she made a life here, and it is her home. It is never discussed that she might return to India, that is not where she belongs any more. She still speaks Hindi to her child and prays every day, but she also starts a business in America and has white friends here and dreams the American dreams. And the film honors her for that, it doesn’t try to squeeze her back into a sari and the kitchen, it is proud of what she has accomplished and the new identity she has built. This is what all NRI women should be like, really all Indian female characters, proud and strong of who they are all on their own, not carrying the weight of the whole nation on their backs.

Related image

9 thoughts on “NRI Week: The Soiled NRI Woman, Purab Aur Paschim, DDLJ, Befikre, and My Name is Khan

    • I’m glad you liked it! You are my expert on white ladies in Indian film, and this is definitely related. Only it’s an Indian woman acting white, so she can be “reformed” while the actual white lady is disposable.

      On Thu, Aug 15, 2019 at 8:19 AM dontcallitbollywood wrote:

      >

      Like

      • White women can be reformed too. There is one Kamal Haasan’s movie with white character. I haven’t seen the movie but read the plot and the woman behaved indian than indians so she was good.
        I’m so fed up with this kind of plot. I want a mainstream good movie with white girl who is white and doesn’t change and is badass.

        Like

        • Befikre! I mean, she’s still desi, but she is also aggressively French and doesn’t change.

          On Thu, Aug 15, 2019 at 8:38 AM dontcallitbollywood wrote:

          >

          Like

        • I mean, Stephanie in Salaam e Ishq doensn’t change and definitely fails at being Indian but I think she does give up her life in Canada to be the wife of a taxi driver, so who knows. Although the movie doesn’t really say, maybe Raju moves to Canada. Anyway, not a big enough part.

          Liked by 1 person

          • I love Stephanie in Salaam-E-Ishq! But as I see her, she is a white woman who aspires to be a “proper” Indian wife to an upperclass man, and then instead ends up being a “proper” Indian wife to a taxi driver. She still gives up her white identity, just for a lowclass option instead of a high class one.

            On Thu, Aug 15, 2019 at 1:36 PM dontcallitbollywood wrote:

            >

            Like

  1. Your last paragraph reminded me of an interview I saw with Karan Johar once. He talked about how when he made K3G, he has this idea in his head that NRIs all dream of India and returning there and that it’s a big part of their daily life. But when he started traveling more and started meeting NRIs, he started to realize that it’s not actually like that. He started to understand that they’re desi in some sense but their lives don’t revolve around India and they don’t dream about moving back there so he tried to incorporate that when he made KANK and My Name is Khan. He stopped the patriotic songs and overdone India-centric drama because he realize these people are happy where they are and they don’t live the way he had imagined it in his head when he made K3G.

    Like

    • Thank you! What an interesting insight. I think he brought that out a bit in ADHM too? Anushka tries to go home and can’t, ends up returning to London. Ranbir travels all over but doesn’t consider going back to India. In a completely fantastical unrealistic way of course, not the grounded hairdresser and salesman style of MNIK, but still the idea that India is not a place they want to be any more.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.