I’ve sat with this movie for a bit, and I think it is more like Tiger 1 than I gave it credit for, in that it is a relationship story wrapped up in an action movie. Think of it as the Indian “Before Sunrise” series! With explosions.
Whole plot in two paragraphs:
Salman rescues his old friend Ranvir Shorey, but Ranvir is already dying, and before he dies he warns Salman that Kat is a double agent for a new terrorist group. Salman returns home to find his son sick with a virus and Kat the same as always, and finally manages to squash his doubts just in time to take another off the books mission in Russia, saving an informant from this same terrorist group. In the course of which he ends up fighting Kat herself! Who is working for the bad guys! Salman is captured and then Emraan Hashmi reveals that he has been slowly poisoning their son and Kat worked for him in order to save their son’s life. And he reveals his backstory, he was Kat’s friend and mentor, but then he went rogue and ordered an assisination of an Indian general against orders. Kat sneakily alerted the Indian spy group (not knowing that the man she was alerting would be HER FUTURE HUSBAND) which lead to Salman taking out the sniper aiming at the general WHO WAS EMRAAN’S PREGNANT GIRLFRIEND. Which is why Emraan really really hates both of them, and also thinks he should be running Pakistan because it would all be better if his plan had worked out. Salman immediately agrees to do whatever it takes to save his son and he and Kat go off on mission together to steal a suitcase. Salman calls in his old RAW buddy Kumud Mishra to help, and two young spies volunteer to join in because they hero worship Salman. Salman is captured in the course of the mission and Kat gives the suitcase thing to Emraan. Salman is handed over to the Pakistani government as a prisoner to be tortured and hung, and the Pakistani agents and Indian agents (some of the same people from Tiger 2! Continuity!) work together to track down Kat. INTERMISSION
Meanwhile, Shahrukh saves Salman from prison. They all reunite at the apartment in Islamabad where Kat and Salman’s adopted son (from Tiger 2) is now living. Kat and Salman tell them Emraan’s plan, to use Salman as a scape goat for a coo, kill the Prime Minister of Pakistan with the help of the army, and take her place as the new leader. The Salman and Kat team sneak into the capital compound and have a really very large number of fight scenes with the Evil Army People Etc. Along the way it is revealed that one of their group is a double agent, because his sister was the Dead Pregnant Girlfriend of Emraan and he ALSO hates Kat and Salman. Salman and Kat’s older adopted son ends up sacrificing himself to save them all, Salman defeats Emraan and Kat has a moment with him as he dies, and then they are hailed as heroes and go back to obscurity, reunited with their one remaining son. HAPPY ENDING SONG.

Two great things about this plot. First, it’s an old school Main Hoon Na style plot where the People of the two countries, and the Democratically Elected Leaders of the two countries, all want peace. It’s just the damaged crazy selfish rebels who do not. Second, it 100% puts personal relationships over idealogy. Why is Emraan bad? Because his girlfriend was killed. Why are Kat and Salman doing tricky things? Because their son is in danger. Why did that one guy end up being a double agent? Because his sister was killed. No one REALLY has a good reason for all this hatred of a whole community, it’s just petty personal BS that has been expanded until it feels bigger.
The most important moment to me is when Salman is captured and is learning that Kat turned double agent to save their son. Emraan is asking Salman to work for him too, and Kat is saying “no, please don’t make him” and also “he would never”. It’s a combination of her loving him so much that she doesn’t want to put him in the same terrible moral area she is, and believing that he will put his morals above personal feelings and rather die than help. And in response, Salman says “I’ll do whatever”. He loves his wife and son more than even Kat expected, does not care about patriotism or country or any of that.
That’s the thesis statement for the film. Love your family! Value the little things! It even goes back to when Emraan is sending his girlfriend out as an assassin. She offers, because she loves and believes in him, and he says “no” because she is pregnant, to which she says their unborn child should be proud to be part of doing such a Noble Mission. And that’s STUPID!!!! These two people made a stupid stupid decision, it lead to one of them being killed and the other arrested, and it all could have been avoided if they hadn’t bought into the Noble Mission and Patriotism stuff and instead said “you know, we’ve got a baby on the way, maybe we DON’T go crazy right now”.
Kat’s backstory is in this movie too, it’s a movie about her character more than Salman’s in terms of plot points, and her backstory fits perfectly with the “Zoya” we have come to know, the one who is fearless and strong and all those things, but also ready to follow love into the unknown. We see her raised in London by a schoolteacher father who she knows is also an ISI undercover agent. And then her Dad dies, blown up when she is a teenager. Emraan Hashmi shows up at the funeral and recruits her. We knew from the first movie that her father was dead, and she loved him, and it was to honor him that she joined ISI. But now we get to see it, and see how Emraan and the agency became her new family, and then how that family was taken away too when Emraan betrayed her JUST before she met Salman. It explains what was in her that let her take a leap and leave with Salman in an attempt to find love and a new family, and it explains what is in her now in this film as she lies and hides what she is doing from Salman to protect him, while also protecting their son. She’s all about family and loyalty and love, she lost it twice (her father’s death and Emraan’s betrayal) and she is not going to lose it again. Loyalty to a country comes far behind loyalty to your family.
Which isn’t to say the film doesn’t also support a bigger view. Kat and Salman really really want to stop Emraan! It’s not a patriotic thing though, it’s just about People. The people of Pakistan deserve peace and a good leader, so they will try to make that happen. Forget politics and borders, just do what needs to be done to save lives.
Wrapped up with all these nice messages, and fun action sequences, is the growth of the Salman-Katrina relationship. In Tiger 1, they fell completely in love to the point of insanity, running off together to live out a fantasy. In Tiger 2, we see them settled with a young child and big romantic gestures, but a lack of communication when Salman takes up his secret mission and expects Kat to stay behind. Now, they communicate so well no words are required. It’s hugs and talking about the kid and family time, and their other adopted son in Pakistan, and old stories that they both already know. Kat knows all about Ranvir Shorey and how sad Salman must be that he is dead. Salman knows about Emraan Hashmi and how he mentored Kat. When they are working together to steal the suitcase of whatever, they are a well-oiled machine, especially as they trick those working with them. Even when Salman thinks she might be a spy, he doesn’t confront her or have a fight it seems like more a matter of gathering evidence for his own satisfaction, he would never turn her in or break up their household. This couple is rock solid.
Correction it was not pregnant girlfriend but pregnant wife
LikeLike
TY! I wasn’t sure.
LikeLike
+1 Emran Hashmi reminded me of Sunil Shetty in Main Hoon Na!!!
LikeLike
YES! Including the ridiculous old man wig!
LikeLike
Another angle was not just about saving people in Pakistan. The references to sasural (in-laws’ home), mayka (home of origin) and son in law were saying that no matter what India and Pakistan are related and joint and how therefore that’s reason enough for the Indian agents to help save their democracy
LikeLike
And if Pathaan ever marries Rubina, he would be related to Afghanistan, Pakistan and India
LikeLike
There’s was another woman hooting when Shahrukh came on. I managed to identify her, chat with her and exchange numbers after the movie. So proud of myself. Want to make more SrK fan friends locally
LikeLike
I am so proud of you too!!!!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
great!!! allthebest 🙂
LikeLike
Did people stand in your theatre during Indian national anthem instrumental? It felt a bit to me like emotionally manipulating nris…
In my theatre only about 50% stood. I was angered by the laziness of the audience there
LikeLike
I’ve been in theaters before where almost everyone stood, so I know it can happen. My theater was only about 8 people besides us and we were front row and they were behind us. So I have no idea! In my experience, it’s more common in the full theaters. When it’s only a few people, somehow it feels weird to stand.
LikeLike
“. . . to use Salman as a scape goat for a coo” — coup? scapegoat?
Although I kind of like “coo.”
LikeLike
Yes coup 😃
LikeLike
The motorcycle chase on the rooftops in the beginning reminded me so much of Fan chase!
LikeLike
YES!!!! And they had the same fake ID and sneak in as kitchen workers plan as Gaurav did in Fan!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Watched today with some family in Virginia Beach, VA. My son had never seen an Indian film. He really liked it & was impressed with film quality. Granddughter said Zoya reminded her of Ziva (NCIS)- too cute. We all loved Shah Rukh’s screen moments and really liked the film. For me, it was worth the 5 hour drive from NC. And, even better was weekend time with family.
LikeLike
Wow! 5 hours! (one way or return?)
Zoya is one of the driving forces of this movie, I feel.
LikeLike
5 hours each way. Most important was family visit. And thrilled my son wants to watch more Indian movies. Otherwise would go to Raleigh, NC – 2 hours each way. My town (Wilmington NC) is an Indian movie desert🧐
LikeLike
Didn’t Wilmington feature in MNIK??
LikeLike
Wilmington, California (a section in LA)
LikeLike
Wilmington, CA – a section in LA
LikeLike
Thanks for the review, Margaret! I would like so much to post both your reviews in the forum I frequent but the discussion culture isn’t what it is here…too much negativity…
LikeLike
Anupama Chopra’s review is very interesting. Also clearly she is an SRK fan. 😃 and she also calls the climax manipulative, which is what I felt!
LikeLike
Hey, she LITERALLY wrote the book on him (if you havent’ read King of Bollywood, go do that RIGHT NOW). FYI, Anupama started out a massive SRK fan and friend, going back to the early 90s when she was a rookie reporter interviewing this up and coming actor. And then somehow about 5 years ago she took a turn and started just HATING on pretty much everything he did. I’m glad to hear she has swung back round again.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wasn’t there something that happened where he said something and she wrote something ugly? I saw some snippets somewhere of SRK saying how he thought he was in a safe conversation and later it blew up or some such thing
LikeLike
Yeah, I don’t remember all the details, but it was something like that. They seem to have mended their relationship since then, but she was blowing up a lot of bridges around that time. Seemed more focused on getting her website up and running and getting clicks than on nurturing relationships.
LikeLike
Ugly business
LikeLike
He’s not doing any more interviews and I guess the last ones were with her
LikeLiked by 1 person
I like that he’s not doing interviews. Seems like he’s finally looking after his mental health and self preservation
LikeLike
Absolutely. And there’s no need for interviews any more, not in the age of social media. If he wants to announce something, he can just announce it.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yeah and the fans really understand his heart and don’t need him to keep talking about it anymore
LikeLike
Even the press meets are done with the whole team so he isn’t so exposed and vulnerable to people tearing him down
LikeLiked by 1 person
I ordered a used copy of her book and I think it’s supposed to get delivered today 😀
LikeLike
Would be interested in our thoughts about the book. I liked it.
LikeLike
I really liked the movie as it was a tight script but also gave some moral greyness. Yes, Tiger and Zoya are saving their child’s life but also giving a terrorist control which might damage a 1000 more lives. That slight amount of selfishness really was refreshing to see in a commercial action film. I did think the film could have cut some moments from the climax as there were too many twists and I need to know who killed Zoya’s father. I did like the last part of Emraan still having Zoya’s fathers watch and also the fact that after a point it wasn’t because of his wife and just he was plain power hungry. Overall it was a good movie but I do think it could’ve been more engaging by cutting down the climax.
LikeLike
Also did anyone else feel the sound design was sloppy? Or was it just my theatre
LikeLike
I think it might have just been your theater. My theater was promoted as enhanced experience blah blah and the sound was great. Maybe it just requires a Dolby system?
LikeLike
Sounds was good in my theatre
LikeLike
I also saw this awful article claiming the movie is misogynistic in its portrayal of Katrina because of that sauna scene. Movies like Jagga Jasoos showed a more ‘feminist’ approach. Jagga Jasoos? Katrina literally doesn’t have any personality beyond helping quirky Ranbir. Do people not understand character motivations?
https://www.filmcompanion.in/features/bollywood-features/making-a-case-for-katrina-kaifs-comedies
LikeLike
Shocker, Film Companion article calls something misogynistic (sarcasm). And yeah, I love Kat as a comedian, but she is GREAT in Tiger 3 and has all kind of juicy motivations and individual problems and things.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am more irritated at the Jagga Jasoos praise. Katrina barely has a role and is a manic pixie dream girl. While in Tiger, she is so so much more. I do wish they would’ve completed her arc but it was still amazing that they made Katrina a true heroine as the film basically exists because of her.
LikeLike
Exactly!!! She was Emraan nemesis, and Tiger only gets involved because she is involved.
LikeLike
Yes! It was messy, of course they were going to do whatever it took to save their child and worry about the future later. But in a different film, they would have been the “bad guys” for doing that. And yes, Emraan started out trying to sell it as revenge, but by the end he was back to just wanting power which is why Kat turned on him in the first place.
LikeLike
I felt like the big reveal would be that Emran killed Katrina’s father in order to recruit her. But it didn’t happen 🤣
LikeLike
Same! Except not to recruit her, but the same way he abandoned Kat. Like her, her father disagreed with him philosophically and he killed him.
LikeLike
Clearly we can write better plots than Adi. Lol just kidding
LikeLike