I already put up my no spoilers review, this is the review with spoilers, assuming you have already seen the movie. Or can’t quite bring yourself to watch it but still kind of want to know what happens. In that case, I am here for you!
The opening and closing are brilliant. That alone is enough to make the film stand out. We open after the incident happens, with two cars, one with three boys and one with three girls. One of the boys has a massive eye injury, the other two are freaking out and hurrying to the hospital. Meanwhile, in the other car, one of the women is leaning on the other while she comforts her, the third is just looking into space. They are also fighting a little, saying “I said we should leave! I said we should get out of there!” The car swerves, and the woman sitting by herself volunteers to sit up front and talk to the driver to keep him awake. While the boys are sitting in the hospital waiting to learn if their friend will lose his eye, the women arrive back home, go into their apartment, and immediately go to their separate rooms.
Now, from the promotions we already know more or less what happened. Heck, even without the promotions, we could put it together from just common sense! 3 guys, 3 girls, somebody went to far, and one of the girls slugged him in the eye. Looking at the aftermath, three girls going home with no injuries, while the boy is almost losing an eye, and the doctor says he could have died if the bottle he was hit with hadn’t shattered, it looks pretty cut and dried. One of these people is the injured party, and one isn’t. What could possibly justify that kind of an injury?
(Different version of 3 guys and 3 girls)
And then the film goes on. We see the girls and boys in the succeeding days. The girls’ reaction is to want to forget about it, to snap at each other and be grim, but otherwise move on with their lives. The boys are the ones who want revenge. This is what I talked about in my non-spoiler review, with the way that bullying can come from the ones who already have all the power. Because they get off on wielding that power. While those who are already down below are used to just shutting up and taking the abuse.
Not that everyone is exactly the same. There are 4 distinctive personalities from the boys’ side, and 3 from the girls’. The injured party is the most powerful one, the nephew of a politician. He almost never speaks, just assumes everyone else will figure things out and do for him before he has to do for himself. He has two friends, “Dumpy” in glasses who is always getting bossed around, driving for them, and so on. He’s a Beta, not able to come up with plans or make decisions on his own. But there’s a little smile, you can see he enjoys being around all these people who enable him to do all the terrible things he wouldn’t be brave enough to do on his own. His other friend seems a little unsure, he’s face is always unhappy whenever the camera catches it. He isn’t strong enough to speak up and loudly object, or to pull out of his association with the others, but it makes him unhappy. And then there’s the third friend. The one who wasn’t even there that night. Who suddenly shows up for the first time when they are hiding out in a hotel room and someone has to pick up the phone and talk to the uncle. He takes the phone and reassures that he will handle things. And he does, he controls the plans and the harassment for the next sequence. He is smarter than the politician’s nephew, and better at seeing the possibilities and the next steps. And, seemingly, a little more vicious. He really enjoys using his power by association to destroy others.
On the girls side, there is Taapsee, clearly the strongest one. Her reaction to threatening phone calls is to ask them to come get her. And Andrea, the weakest one, the one who needed to be comforted that night, she reacts by seeming sad and scared and talking to her boyfriend for support. And then there’s Kirti (my favorite!), who reacts by constantly looking for the compromise. She talks to the unsure friend on the boys’ side, they both want this to just be over.
And what is “this”, exactly? It starts out with lowlevel stuff that you feel like you can ignore, you can’t call the police on, maybe it will just blow over. The first move is to call their landlord, late at night, and tell him that he is renting to prostitutes and it would be better if he kicked them out. And this is also the first time the film zigged when I thought it would zag. I was all set for their old man landlord to throw them out immediately. But no, he reacts by going to talk to them and checking to make sure no one has been harassing them. He reacts like a kind and intelligent person, aware of how the world works, not like a reactionary blindly believing anything anyone tells him.
That’s the brilliance of the film, start to finish, people don’t react like evil villains. They react as kindly as possible, those who know the girls believe them, and those who don’t, or have some reason for gaining an advantage, don’t believe them. Even Amitabh, who isn’t the kindly landlord or anyone else in their lives. He is just their neighbor, their kind of odd neighbor who goes for long walks in his oxygen training mask in the mornings while they jog. And who sometimes seems to be watching them while he stands on his balcony at night. But he believes them, not for any big grand reason, but just because, well, why wouldn’t he?
Also believing them are Taapsee’s boss, who takes her to a personal contact in the police who believes her as well. Andrea and Kirti’s boyfriends’ believe them as well, but also don’t offer to ride in and rescue them, instead just providing a little advice and support but otherwise leaving them alone. And the thing is, they don’t want or need advice and support. Because they have that in each other. Kirti and Andrea especially, we later find out, have no one else to rely on. Kirti’s father is dead or gone and she is the primary support for her mother and younger brother. Andrea is from the Northeast and clearly has no relatives living nearby in Delhi. Whether their situation made them strong, or they landed in this situation because they were already the strongest ones, either way, they are not the type to be interested in the usual male-female relationship. They don’t want a boyfriend who is into every part of their life, who swoops in to rescue them when things go wrong. They want someone who will stay nicely segregated in his own little space in their world.
(So, not this. No big fantasy that overwhelms them until they ignore everything else in life. And in the end, forgive their sister’s killer because they loooooove him.)
It’s the girls themselves who are the ones to share their whole lives, to have each others backs, to be the ones who know everything and are always there. It doesn’t come through clearly in the first scene, I was actually kind of mad about that, the way they went to separate corners as soon as they got home. But then the film continues, and it was really showing how the shock of the initial event served to drive them apart. But then, as the outside attacks continued, they came ever closer and closer. The turning point is after all 3 of them have been fighting their separate battles for a while. Their landlord was threatened, not just over the phone but in person. The boys kept calling and calling on each of their cell phones. Taapsee tried to file a police report, without talking to the other two, and was turned off by the police’s usual “Well, are you sure that’s what you want? It will be hard, I’m just saying this for your own good” attitude towards sexual assault complaints. And then tried again, more successfully, with the support of her boss. Andrea was followed while she was with her boyfriend, getting away by ducking down an alley. And then, finally, they are all sitting together and Kirti declares that they are ending this right now, calling and apologizing, compromising. Like I said in my other review, Kirti is really the leader of the group. She declares this, Taapsee objects but goes along.
And then on the phone call, while Kirti keeps apologizing and apologizing and talking about compromise, the “leader” of the boys, the one who has controlled this whole campaign, keeps demanding in increasingly abusive language to talk directly to Taapsee, to get her to apologize. And that is when Kirti finally snaps, telling him he can’t talk about Taapsee like that and they have nothing to apologize for! And from that moment on, all 3 girls are committed to each other and on the same page.
(no real song sequences in the movie, this seems as good a point as any to drop in this promotional video)
Which is good, because that’s when the boys up their campaign. First, they abduct Taapsee. Which is also when Amitabh gets involved for the first time. Not as a big hero, but as a regular decent person. He sees Taapsee be taken, and then calls the police, and calls again, and again, when he can sense that there is no response. And then calls his higher up connections, trying to get something to happen. And when Taapsee is returned, after being threatened by the “leader” and molested by Dumpy, Amitabh watches her go safely back into her apartment. He could have chased after the truck, he could have rushed over to see her when she arrived, he could have done a lot of things. I mean, not really, not an old man who can barely walk through the park. But the scriptwriters could have made him do those things, made him been a real “hero”. But instead, he didn’t even get the license plate of the car. It’s the girls who go above and beyond. Taapsee comes home, and they put her in a shower, comfort her, take care of her. Kirti sets aside her own concerns, her loss of her job, and focuses on taking care of Taapsee.
And they stay focused on her, when the police arrive the next day to arrest her for attempted murder, a case filed by the politician’s nephew. It is the girls who wait all day to see her, the girls who find a lawyer, the girls who try to raise bail. And when Amitabh finally meets them, he just tells them what they need to know, asking to see the arrest papers and letting them know they do have the right to bail, even for a “non-bailable offense” if it is a female accused. Everything else is still up to them, they have the right to take care of themselves. That’s really what Amitabh’s whole defense rests on. Because, of course he takes up their case!
After they beg him to, after they have researched him and found that he is a former superstar lawyer who took leave to treat his manic-depression. Which is the reason I mentioned in my non-spoiler review for his deadened affect. His personal power and charisma slowed and tamped down. Not because of the disease, but the treatment. He is taking his pills every night, we see that, and presumably they are doing their job of keeping his swings under control. Amitabh has been beaten down by life, he is down at the bottom with the 3 girls, trying to fight back against overwhelming unfair odds just like them.
But, even with all of that, he is still Amitabh. There is a moment, when he spends the night at the bedside of his sick wife, and the sun rises and he turns his head and you know he has made his decision to help them, and, I don’t know, just looking at the back of his head, suddenly I got choked up! Because, you know, it’s Amitabh! Coming in and giving an amazing performance in an amazing movie at the end of his career because he wants to help these girls. Not the characters in the film, but the women in real life, who are struggling with all of society being against them, judging them, never believing them, never offering a hand or anything approaching human decency. And here’s Amitabh, taking this last phase of his career to be their champion.
(No idea what this is saying, but doesn’t it send chills down your spine?)
And the second half of the film shows how he is their champion, their true champion who never blames them for anything and keeps his eye clearly on the salient moral points, not letting himself be blinded by flotsam and jetsum set to confuse the issues. The boys say that they filed a case right away. That the girls are prostitutes who beat them when they refused to pay. That the police had been watching them and it was clearly a conspiracy. Amitabh disproves some of it, but some of it he doesn’t even bother with. Yes, the girls met them at a rock concert. Yes, the girls live alone not with their families. Yes, the girls have jobs and boyfriends and lives. Yes, they had a drink. Yes, they went back to the hotel rooms. He doesn’t bother to deny any of it.
You know how in movies, the heroine always has to get drunk before she does the sexy song? Because otherwise it would be “wrong”? That’s what Amitabh is fighting back against here. It’s never wrong! They did nothing wrong! You can be sexual and happy and free without being punished, because you are doing nothing wrong! He even forces Taapsee, on the stand, to admit she isn’t a virgin. That she had slept with a few men, in fact. And that, possibly, one of the boys knew that, the one who seemed the most unhappy with what they were doing, he was her old friend from school and might have heard rumors. And you know what? The world doesn’t end! Taapsee doesn’t die of shame or try to kill herself. It can all continue, just like before. Even when Kirti breaks on the stand and gives in to the prosecution’s badgering and says “Fine! We asked for money!”, even that doesn’t matter. These things only matter if we believe they matter.
That’s the point of the last scene of the film before the coda. The girls have won their case. The boys are going to jail. But, they have had their reputations smeared and their dirty laundry aired. They should be sad, right? But no. We get just a quick glimpse of the 3 of them, standing on their balcony, smiling in the sunlight. Because none of that really matters. They have each other, they have their freedom, they don’t need anything else.
That’s what bothered me so much about, for instance, Drishyam. The idea that girls are ruined as soon as someone spreads a dirty picture of them online or a rumor or anything else. Why are they ruined? Just because they can’t marry some guy who would care about something like that? Or work for someone who would care? Or visit family who care? Why would you want to be with any of those people anyway? And, more importantly, this is the kind of thinking that leads people to just give up instead of fighting back. Say “yes, this is who I am and this is what I did and if you have a problem, that is your problem, not mine” and you will be so much happier! That’s what this movie is showing, that these girls are happy in the end, because they have fought through all the shame and blame and trials society has thrown at them and come out the other side happier and stronger for it.
And then there’s the coda. Which Amitabh tweeted I should stay for, so I did. All through the trial we were hearing different versions of what happened. Even the girls weren’t really clear, there was something about Andrea needing a restroom, so “Dumpy” took her to another room (where he molested her), and then Kirti went aside for fresh air with the school friend, and then something happened, the politician’s nephew “grabbed” Taapsee or “touched” her, or something, she keeps using different phrases in her testimony. And she was a little drunk and maybe overreacted and she hit him with a bottle. We only see the aftermath all along, going all the way back to the opening with the three guys rushing to the hospital and the three girls rushing home. And as time passes, everyone is very unclear about what exactly happens, it gets very confused. We know they boys are evil, that they overreacted, that the girls aren’t prostitutes and they didn’t set out to attack the boys. But the actual evening in question, it feels like maybe it just got exaggerated, like Taapsee lost control of her temper, like there could have been another way to get out of it.
And then after all of that, after the tricks our minds always play when we hear these stories, thinking that it couldn’t have really been that bad, we see it all play out, silently, in little snapshots, over the end credits. The girls getting uncomfortable and trying to leave, the boys exchanging glances and clearly working out a plan, and then Taapsee alone in the room, trying to leave, being grabbed, being shoved against a wall, being yanked about, trying to pull away, trying to hit back, and it just goes on and on! The snapshot effect is brilliant too, because it lets us really study each moment as it happens, no hiding from it, no saying “oh, I’m sure there was another way.” There wasn’t any other way, she was about to be raped, she was fighting as hard as she could, and she wasn’t going to win. And by the time she grabs the bottle and hits him, you are desperate for it to just be over, for her to get out of there anyway she can.
That’s what the movie wants you to leave with. That all of this talk and aftermath and discussion is nothing, is worth it. That Taapsee did the right thing and we should all be glad she did, that she did whatever she needed in the moment. And we should trust her judgement in that moment, she should have trusted her own judgement, her friends should have trusted her judgement, and there should never have been a question of “why did she do it, did she have to do it, this is what she should have done.” She was a grown woman with a mind and judgement of her own, and she was the one who was actually there! We should give her support and encouragement and faith. And that’s why this part came right at the end. We, the audience, had to be in the same position as everyone else for the rest of the film, taking it on faith alone. No easy out of seeing it happen on camera. If you can believe a character in a movie just because she says so, why can’t we believe people in real life?
Pingback: Ready to be in Awe of Corporate Stupidity? Oh, Also, Casting News! | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Global Box Office Report: Such a Strange Pink Pattern! | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Veruthe Oru Bharya: ENRAGING!!! | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Box Office Report! Dhoni is Bringing In People For the Story | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Happy Birthday Amitabh!!! Finale!!! (Part 3) | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Weekend Box Office: Hilariously Bad | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Box Office, Censorship, and Casting News | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Dear Zindagi SPOILER Review: This is a Movie Made For Women, Start To Finish | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Dear Zindagi NO SPOILERS Review: The Biggest Flaw is Shahrukh’s Hotness | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Koffee With the Khan Boys! (Don’t Get Excited, It’s Sallu and His Brothers, not SRK and Sallu and Aamir) | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: 2016 In Film on DCIB Blog: Readers Choice Post! VOTE HERE! – dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Readers Choice Awards 2016 – dontcallitbollywood
I finally watched Pink and I’m surprised that there are actually no comments on both of your Pink reviews.
Like you Pink has reached my expectations but not exceeded them. I loved the message of the movie but based on the trailer I was expecting a more intense movie. By the way, when reading the imdb message boards and I saw this analysis of Amitabh’s character:
“When I was watching this movie, Amitabh’s character felt strangely eerie. But when the movie started to show his character and I looked closely i understood why he was like that. He was over vigilante because of the Anxiety disorder. He wears a mask when he is outside, he goes for walk in the deer park daily and opens up the mask when he is beneath the tree. He stays away from people. He has emotional outbursts, it takes a lot of time for him to say things.
It is shown that he quit his service, probably because of depression and Polar disorder, he is not Confident of himself, he talks at very low volume, its hard to hear him sometimes. We see him preparing for his Wife’s death when he takes the thumb impression of her in insurance papers for making himself a nominee. After that comes a dialogue which when connected with the dialogue in the end probably connects the character well and is a defining moment in the movie:
His wife sighs and says, “I wish you also had a nominee” What we witness through this dialogue is that they have no children.
then jokingly she says, ” Soch Lo, I am still ready to have some just like Always”
This dialogues then shows that Amitabh either had a problem or just never wanted to have children.
In the end then Amitabh says in the court: No! Means No!. Its not just a word, its a complete sentence in itself. No Matter who says this to you, NO MEANS NO..She can be your friend, GirlFriend, sex-worker, even your wife! This dialogue proves the point that Amitabh do not want any children, perhaps he did not want children because he was afraid to have them, but more than that the way he says this proves that he said no, he refused and his wife accepted and lived on with it. Because No Means No”
What do you think about this?
Thanks for commenting! This review, by the way, is part of the reason I am so obsessed about seeing new releases opening night and putting up reviews and summaries ASAP. I missed Pink the first two weeks it was out, and then there were no comments and minimal views for my posts.
And thanks for pasting the idea from IMDB! The first part, I think, kind of lines up with my thinking about it. Amitabh’s character was restrained and had a low affect in response to anti-psychotic medication. And, from a narrative side of things, they came up with this idea so that Amitabh wouldn’t overly dominate the film, his character could step back a little and let the women shine.
I don’t know about the interpretation of the “no means no” related to their lack of children. I love the connection, but I would see it in a slightly different way. Women are so often seen as only worthwhile for their bodies, for either procreational or recreational sex. Amitabh loves his wife and has no children with her. Meanwhile he sees her as more than just a potential mother. Either they made the choice together not to have children, or it was Amitabh’s choice, or one or both of them was not physically capable. Either way, it means their relationship was about him seeing her as a person and loving her for herself, not her body’s ability to create life.
On Mon, Jan 23, 2017 at 8:02 AM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:
It’s still surprising that there were no comments since Pink was one of those movies that was talked about quite a bit.
About the imdb post, I thought it was a really interesting way to look at why Amitabh’s character didn’t have children.
I was wondering afterwards, how do you think the dynamic of the movie would have changed if the girls’ lawyer had been someone who was younger than Amitabh or even another woman?
If it had been a woman, it would have been another message of “women should save themselves and the rest of society can sit back and relax and do nothing”. And it if had been a younger man, firstly, it would have opened up the possibility of a romance which would have been a HUGE mistake. And secondly, again, it would have said that the older generation is hopeless, the younger generation is the one that has to fix society.
I think using Amitabh was important because the message he was giving wasn’t for women, women know this, it was to men. And an older man, especially an older man played by Amitabh, is the perfect way to give a message from and to the patriarchy that No means No, women can have sex without being punished for it, and all that other great stuff.
I just watched this last night on Netflix.
It was so well made and everyone did a great job.
I kept wondering whether we will actually get to see what happened that night and I agree – the snapshot effect worked really well. I really didn’t want to see more because it was making me uncomfortable and I wanted Minal to get out of that room.
Well done to Amitabh for picking a movie like this.
Well-done to Amitabh indeed! This is one of those times where it feels like “this film would never have gotten made if a big name hadn’t given the go ahead”. It is just such an odd narrative structure and controversial storyline and everything else. They really need one big person to say “yes, use my name” before it could get off the ground.
On Thu, Jan 26, 2017 at 3:57 PM, dontcallitbollywood wrote:
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: Hindi Film 101 One-Off: Amitabh, from ABCL to Mohabbatein by way of KBC – dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Bhootnath: SRK With Bad Hair or Priyanshu Chatterjee, Who Is Hotter? – dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Happy International Women’s Day! Here are some International Women! – dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Silly Sunday Speculative Post: Rani Week Edition! What Would My Ideal Rani Comeback Film Look Like? – dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Monday Malayalam: Udayananu Tharam Asks Does the Film Create the Star or the Star Create the Film? – dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Two News Items Too Big To Ignore: National Film Awards and New Shahrukh Stills! – dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Hindi Film 101: Woman Filmmakers, Why So Few? – dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Happy Birthday Amitji! 75 Reasons I Love You! | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Film Reviews | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Netflix List for October!!!! And This Time, Nothing is “Must Watch” | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Netflix List for November!!!! | dontcallitbollywood
Pingback: Valentine’s Day Announcements! Upcoming Films And More | dontcallitbollywood
I saw this movie when I was 16/17, and the scene where Kirti “admits” on the prosecution stand that they took money from the boys made a big impression on me. My immediate response to it was “No! Why is she lying under oath? Why is she making the case harder to defend? She should stand her ground and not be bullied!” Then my mom pointed out that a) we don’t know this at that point (because they only show the incident at the end) and more importantly b) it shouldn’t matter and it doesn’t matter. The prosecution’s case shouldn’t rest on the line of defense “you were paid for sex so you should give it”. Even if they were prostitutes who were paid, their no means no too.
For a girl raised in India and taught not to be like “those girls” by society, this was a huge eye-opener.
Also I realise I am four years too late to this conversation! Ah well, I just wanted to add my little words of appreciation for this post.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes! It’s such a great twist. And I think it is even better that it is a lie. The ultimate point needs to be “it doesn’t matter, no means no”. But I like that it is a lie and they don’t bother to correct it. These “good” girls do not worry about being wrongly stuck with the label of sex worker, because there is no necessary shame in that.
On Fri, Jan 22, 2021 at 8:36 AM dontcallitbollywood wrote:
LikeLiked by 1 person
This scene, and the scene where Taapsee reveals that she first had sex at 19, were both instrumental for me to start questioning things that I had passively imbibed as a young teenager.
LikeLiked by 1 person