Salman and the IMPPA Disagree

Yesterday I reported that rumor that Salman called Raj Thackeray to ask for mercy for Ae Dil Hai Mushkil and Raees for the good of the film industry.  Today, following up on that, Salman really really put his neck on the line.

First, the IMPPA (Indian Motion Picture Producers Association) announced a ban on all Pakistani artists and technicians.  Backing up a second, who the heck is the IMPPA?  I would have just accepted them as some industry group, except there was just some rumbling in the news about Siddharth Roy Kapur taking over from Mahesh Bhatt as the head of the Film and Television Producers Association of India, a totally separate group.

The IMPPA sounds like an industry group, doesn’t it?  Like a union or labor group.  But, it’s not!!!  At least not so far as I can tell.  It looks like it’s a privately traded company with multiple members that invests in film.  It does have influence in the industry, it has a lot of members and I am sure it has its fingers in a lot of pies, and also does a lot of good for the industry.  But it is not a labor organization, it does not by default speak for the entire industry.  That would be the FTPAI, a totally different not for profit group.  Which I am pretty sure is not going to announce a ban on Pakistani artists, because it is run by Mahesh Bhatt right now who is not that kind of guy.

(He’s the kind of guy who will steal from Pakistani artists and then acknowledge them at the last minute)

Also, I suspect the FTPAI is a more active and forward thinking and wealthy and powerful group just based on the website.  FTPAI looks like what I would expect from a large not-for-profit that cares about its international presence.  The IMPPA looks more like an organization that is a little behind the times, a little slow, and not that interested in reaching out to new members.

But even this slightly old-fashioned group has some people who object to this ban.  Rahul Aggarwal, a member of the IMPPA executive council, submitted his letter of resignation and submitted a copy of that letter to the media.  My favorite quotes are below, you can view the whole thing here.

I strongly feel that art is above politics and as the custodians of this art; it is our responsibility to bring people together rather than divide them….

Banning one another is not the solution, rather bringing everyone together and showing the world that terrorism cannot divide these two great nations can become a beacon for acceptance and hope, two characteristics that are the complete opposites of the fundamentalists that want us to go to war with one another. It is we the people of both countries who have the power to bring real change and I believe that this change could have been brought about by further strengthening our ties with Pakistani artists of all kinds and not banning them…..

Though I strongly condemn the terrorist attack, I believe that the soft power of art is sometimes more effective than the hard line of sanctions and war.

Good letter, right?  The cynical part of me is saying that the IMPPA took this action in order to get good headlines, and Rahul Aggarwal released his letter in order to take part in those headlines.  But it’s still a good letter!

Also, whoa!  He is the son of the IMPPA president!!!  This suddenly turned into some kind of father against son crazy melodrama!!!  Why am I the only one mentioning this?  Maybe I’m miss-reading the information, but I’m pretty sure I am reading it right.  Oh, and the only film credit I am seeing for him is producing Policegiri with Sanjay Dutt.  I feel like working with Sanjay Dutt in recent years would be a good way for people to become open minded.

(I love Trishul)

Okay, after all of that background, you ready to hear how this relates to Salman?  Being Human launched their jewelry line today (yay!), which meant Salman had a press conference.  And he was asked what he thought about the IMPPA ban.  To which he said…HE DOES NOT LIKE IT!!!  From Bollywoodhungama:

“The action taken against terrorists was a proper one. Pakistani artistes are just artists and not terrorists. Terrorism and art are two different subjects.”  He questioned the interviewer asking her, “Do you believe artists are terrorists? They come with a valid visa. Who gives them visa? Our government gives them a visa and work permit.”

Dang, Salman!  I guess of the biggies, he is the only one really able to speak out.  Shahrukh can’t, because it’s affecting his own productions (Raees and Ae Dil Hai Mushkil in which he has a cameo).  Aamir is probably still running scared a little from the last time he took a stand.  And Amitabh usually holds back a little before deciding to speak out.

So, either Salman is going to be left hanging and get himself in trouble (again), or this is going to turn into something like Shahrukh’s birthday “intolerance” comment, and all the others will slowly come around to back him up in their own way.  Or, Salman will back off over the next few days as he realizes he is out there on his own.  Well, him and Rahul Aggarwal.


9 thoughts on “Salman and the IMPPA Disagree

  1. he should have remained silent..its not a silly political conflict..both countries are at the edge of a war..and whole india is backing the army and government including opposition parties..i m not saying to ban all pak artists(and i dont care even if they are banned). but he should have waited till the tides are settled.not the right time to be a rebel..general public is not very interested about the losses o bollywood now..but everything will settle down with some time


    • I was interested, just from the popular culture and PR side of things which is all I am qualified to speak about, that Salman issued this statement in response to a question at an event about something else entirely, and his answer seemed a little off the cuff. I wonder if it was just an accident, that he didn’t have anything rehearsed or planned out and would have just said “No comment” if he’d thought for a moment, but he was caught off guard and ended up speaking about something he didn’t mean to address just yet (if ever).


      • OK, first of all, the IMPPA ban is a “temporary” ban, as they said in their statement, “until the situation between the two countries normalises.” How long will that be? Probably a month or two, is my guess. So the ban isn’t anything dire, and in my view was just made to get some “good optics” as people say nowadays. It also specifically exempted projects already completed, or artists who are currently under contract on a project. So it is really just banning starting any new projects, as of the date of the ban, till the time they lift it, which, as I said, will probably be a couple of months.

        Second, Salman: Ha ha ha ha ha, you really think Salman ever has a “prepared statement” on anything? (except the one time he apologized on twitter, and it was soooo obvious that wasn’t written by him). He *always* speaks off the cuff. That said, his position on not banning Pakistani artistes is consistent with his previous position (many years ago, and actually in support of SRK) in 2009, when he said Pakistani cricket players shouldn’t be banned from playing in the IPL. That was a bit of a “prepared” statement, if you like, in that he first made the statement, then, as he had just started a blog in those days, asked for his fans’ input on what they thought. Of course he ignored everyone who disagreed with him. 🙂

        So I doubt that he would retract his statement. He practically never does, unless it’s a factual error, and this is an opinion, after all.

        And incidentally, a day after the news/rumor came that Salman had spoken to Raj Thackeray to get the MNS to back off on banning Pakistani actors, the MNS released a statement denying that Salman had contacted anyone in their party. And finally, just for your information (since you went to so much trouble to look up the details on IMPPA), the MNS is a political party that currently has zero seats in the state legislature (they’re not active nationally). So they needed a bit of “optics”, too. 🙂


  2. i dont mean he said anything wrong(or right)..but such cries and demands for banning pak artists ,exiling them etc are expected now and understandable in this peculiar situation. but things will change after a period…best thing to do was to remain silent


  3. Pingback: Raj Thackeray Gets Personal, Kareena Has an Industrious Hacker, Nawazuddin I don’t even know what to say | dontcallitbollywood

  4. Pingback: See, Kangana? It’s Not Just Hrithik! Salman’s Dad Supports Him Too. Oh, and I have Issues with Om Puri, But Not Just Because of the Recent Stuff | dontcallitbollywood

  5. Pingback: ADHM Update: Pieces are Moving Into Place For the Final Battle | dontcallitbollywood

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.